Should brambleclaw take squirrelflight back as a mate?

First topic message reminder :

you can choose more than one

rivershine wrote:I don`t like Squirrelflight, but I think that Brambleclaw still likes her and she made him happy. So I want Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight to get back together.But trust me, her and leafpool are the cats I REALLY don`t like. It`s confusing.... xp

I think they'll still get back together ^.^

Me too!

I really hope they become mates again!

WarriorHawkPath wrote:Brambleclaw is clan deputy. That is why SF didnt kept him in the dark! Even if she should have told him, its not like he doesnt have secrets too! I think he should give her another chance. Even though he going to die in 'the forgotten warrior' anyways. I think that 'her kits' should give her another chance too. SF acted as a mother when Leafpool couldnt.
thats just what i think. I voted YES.

I agree entirely. SF was way better than some 'real' mothers in the Warriors series.

Spoiler:

Hopefully her 'foster' kits will realize that and forgive her and Leafpool [just like Bluestar and her kits].

Yeah good point Honeystar i agree with you completly.

In my opinion they both deseved it. Brambleclaw is a spoiled brat and needed some suffering in life instead of another cake and Squirrelflight deserved it because she was a jerk to her neice and nephews for pertending she was there mother.

Squirrelflight deserved to be ignored for a little while, but now, it's getting old and Brambleclaw (And Leafpool's kits) need to grow up. Brambleclaw has his own secrets that he never told Squirrelflight, and Lionblaze and Jayfeather simply don't have any excuse to hold such a long grudge against Squirrelflight. Squirrelflight was an excellent foster mother to them while Leafpool was an unfair and very impateint aunt. When they're was a skirmish between Jafeather and Willowshine in The Sight, Leafpool automatically assumed it was Jayfeather's fault, without even bothering listening to his side of the story. I don't care if she was covering up the fact she is his mother, that is unjust and unfair.

I believe Brambleclaw should not be ignoring Squirreflight like he is. He holds grudges, and I don't like that about his character. Squirrelflight wasn't truthful to him, but she was being loyal to her sister, which is more important, IMHO. *nod*

Yeah. Brambleclaw needs to understand that.

Totally. He's being a snob.

I want to slap him in the face, and say: "Get over it already!!!! She still loves you, and deep down you know , that you love her too!!!!! Don't wait until it's too late to be together again!"

Exactly!! I used to like Brambleclaw, but now he's almost my least favorite character.

Well I still like him [him and Squirrelflight both have personalities similar to me], but honestly he needs stop acting the way he is.

Honestly, I still like Brambleclaw. I loved him and Squirrelflight together, they were my favorite pairing. It's hard for me not to like Bramblecalw though. So my vote is Yes they should be together

Great to hear that you and me are on the same page Emberstrike.

LOL squirrelflight is a loser xDDD

Iceshadow wrote:Squirrelflight should have included Brambleclaw in the secret. I chose No, Squirrelflight is a loser, It was her fault and If Brambleclaw really loved her, he would take her back.

Brambleclaw also needs to understand what Squirrelflight is going through right now...

silly brambleclaw

he should wait for the girl to come back to him XD

I think that Brambleclaw loved Squirrelflight, and that Squirrelflight loved him, but she made a big mistake.
~ Hi, Darkfire! I`m Silentwolf, I don`t believe we`ve met!~

Your so right Silentwolf! But I like Darkfire's idea! LOL!

Ya, me too! XD Of course, that would take FOREVER!

No I think Squirrleflight might come running back! I like Darkfire's idea! XD

She`s not goodenough for Brambleclaw! XD

Squirrelflight should go die in a hole.

Lol! That`s funny, Brightstar! I totally agree!