How do you REALLY feel about Brambleclaw becoming leader?

I don't know, it's just, I feel as though someone else should've been leader. If I had to choose, I'd say that Graystripe would've been an awesome leader.

He's gonna be a good leader but not a great one. He is a very nice cat but he's young so he might make a stupid choice.

Tangleclaw wrote:He's gonna be a good leader but not a great one. He is a very nice cat but he's young so he might make a stupid choice.

That may be true, but because Firestar lived an incredibly long life, Brambleclaw's got plenty of experience. Sometimes, youth and experience fit together perfectly, and besides, Bramblestar's not THAT young. Though I do have reasons to object. Brambleclaw is a bit battle hungry and mean... Remember how he treated Squirrelflight after he knew the truth?

He's a very good choice for the role, but I am still ticked that the Erin's lied to us about getting a different leader. What was the point of misleading us like that? Other than that, I feel that he is definitely going to be an awesome leader and will defend ThunderClan much better than Firestar did. (come on, avoiding battles even when your neighbor is practically declaring war?) Also, he was a much, MUCH better choice than Lionblaze. *shudders*

Did the Erins lie? o.O I don't remember.
But I like Bramblestar. He's experienced and can make good choices. He doesn't dwell on his past and parentage, instead devoting all his energy and loyalty to his Clan.
Graystripe would have been too old because he's a old as Firestar.
And also I don't like Squirrelflight as deputy because her confidence has shrunk.

I like Brambleclaw as the leader. I agree with Noxe, on both Graystripe and Squirrelflight. Graystripe would have the experience but he's sooo old.

I have to agree with Darkflower and Noxe. And squirrelflight is kind of irresponsible. Graystripe is actually old while Bramblestar is young.

I agree with everyone here then. .u. Maple actually.

I like him as a leader but he should have picked Lionblaze as a deputy. I liked that he tried to make it up to her for being so mean, but Lionblaze would have been the better choice.

To me, I think that Bramblestar should've picked a different deputy. I think that his choice was based on... I forget exactly what happened but I think someone else mentioned it (Early onset memory loss, anyone. ) Umm... I guess we'll have to wait until the 6th series and see!

I think Bramblestar should've picked Ivypool to be deputy.I mean, with out her, all the clans would have lost.

Naw, just because Ivypool saved the clans doesn't mean she would be a good deputy. ^^ I think Bramblestar would make a pretty good leader! He's been deputy for a pretty long time and he has nice leadership skills. Lionblaze is a great warrior, but he's literally like the "warrior," made to follow orders. Not a strategist. Squirrelflight was chosen as Bramble's deputy, I think because he felt bad for giving her the cold shoulder? But it was still a pretty good choice. She's got experience!

I think bramblestar was a good choice, lionblaze would have been looking for wars between each clan for moons and there would be more drama between his crush who refuses to accept his power and him as a mate. Squirrelflight was a good choice between making up for the cold shoulder, but she showed devotion to something and that does mean something now she doesn't have to lie about that can devote her time and energy into the clan although I feel as though leafpool needs to be more of a warrior and stop acting like an elder she isn't that old to be moping about just move on, hollyleaf did why cant she?

Its not only that, but she has more fighting skills than any other cat in the warriors series(Because of the dark forest)and is a very good strategist.She also has more experience than most cats her age.

I think Graystripe should have become leader, He's older and more experienced.

Screw my last comment about this. I think that Bramblestar will be a great leader. Although Squirrelflight would not be the best deputy. To me, she seems irresponsible, and has little self confidence since the last arcs. If I were Bramblestar, I would have chosen Graystripe.

Brambleclaw is too ambitious. And the fact that he made SQUIRRELFLIGHT deputy, I mean, COME ON! WHY COULDN'T GRAYSTRIPE BE LEADER?!?