Hollyleaf Debate

by **Redstar** December 18th 2012, 16:47

Personaly, I love Hollyleaf. She reminds me of me in some ways Wink

Tell me what you guys think. But don't get really mad though. It's just a debate/discussion.

by Legendflower December 18th 2012, 16:51

I don't see why anyone doesn't like her. >.>

by **Redstar** December 18th 2012, 16:56

I know Viper doesn't like her. But I agree. I LOVE my Hollyleaf Very Happy

Best character EVER!!! I also love Hawkfrost... BUT THIS IS ABOUT HOLLYLEAF Very Happy

by **Nyx** December 18th 2012, 16:59

I think Hollyleaf's story was an interesting one. ^-^ She's not the super-powerful, does-everything-right kind of cat. She made plenty of mistakes, but also plenty of good choices. Hollyleaf is one of my favorite characters. :]

by Bloodpaw December 18th 2012, 17:19

She's awesome! You could really symathize with her! And Ashfur was NOT innocent!

by Ren December 18th 2012, 17:33

I like Hollyleaf. I think she is a really good cat. Why would Viper not like her? Ashfur wasn't innocent. I like the choices she makes

by **Redstar** December 18th 2012, 17:41

I know Ashfur isn't innocent, but some people think he is. Those people are cray-cray. ;D

by Bloodpaw December 18th 2012, 17:46

I know! He was evil too! So she was justified in killing him.

by Ren December 18th 2012, 18:32

Either way, I believe Hollyleaf did the right thing :3

by Lunarlight December 18th 2012, 19:16

Hollyleaf was protecting herself from Ashfur, who said he was going to kill them, meaning she was not a murderer, she just defended herself.

by **Caraway** December 18th 2012, 20:19

(Dawn, that was a repeated detail so please don't post small comments like that again. It's spammy)

Well I can't really say anything because I didn't read her full story. From what I've heard people either really like her or hate her completely Razz

by **Sunbeam** December 19th 2012, 07:54

I agree. Although, Ashfur didn't deserve to die, he would have shamed ThunderClan, leafpool, Crowfeather and Hollyleaf. Hollyleaf did what she thought was best. If not for the death of Ashfur she would be my favorite character.

by Legendflower December 19th 2012, 09:39

She was defending herself; she's not a Murderer. So why doesn't Viper like her?

by Lunarlight December 19th 2012, 09:53

Gingerblaze, completely agrred. She doesn't like her because she is jelous :3

by **Frost** December 19th 2012, 11:25

Well, at first Hollyleaf was definitely NOT one of my favourite characters. She seemed rather stuck-up and bossy at first to me and I was puzzled why Flameleaf (inactive real-life friend on site) loved her so much. But afterwards, I begin to grow a liking for her so my answer is "I like her."

by **Thunderclaw** December 19th 2012, 16:05

She's okay,but definitly NOT my favorite.She did seem bossy,but she did make mistakes,and killed the cat that would have killed them,though I still don't get why Ashfur went to Starclan.

by **Redstar** December 19th 2012, 17:24

LOL. I agree, Thunderclaw. Ashfur was practically evil... So why not go to the DF? AND, Holly came back, and I LOVE how Bramble defended her <3 But, she died DDDDD:<

by **Stareye** December 19th 2012, 20:05

I could not stand Hollyleaf in the Power of Three. She was hypocritical, whiny, high strung pile of dung. But then she came back from hiding, and she didn't nearly get on my nerves so much. She was alright after that, but I still didn't care much

Spoiler:

by **Caraway** December 19th 2012, 20:59

Remember to respect other peoples' opinions in a debate. If someone doesn't like her, it's okay. They're not wrong and you're not wrong. If Vioer doesn't like her then there's no need to question why or how.

(In a school debate you don't even get to choose your side, so you have to understand both sides and be prepared to argue for either).

by Lunarlight December 19th 2012, 21:06

Arguing helps, until it gets out of hand.

by Illusion December 19th 2012, 21:58

Ashfur wasn't "innocent", he tried to kill Hollyleaf's littermates! Sword

by Legendflower December 20th 2012, 09:04

I liked Ashfur. Stupid Squirrelflight made him go all wacko. :3

Hollyleaf would've made a good leader. (Better than FireStar, if you will Whistle

)

by **Stareye** December 28th 2012, 11:16

I agree with you Gingerblaze. Despite her actions in Sunrise, she learned immensely from them, and she wouldn't turn into a complete pacifistic, judgmental idiot like Firestar either.

by Ren December 28th 2012, 11:26

I think Hollyleaf should've became leader. Firestar is so judgmental and acts like he was never a kittypet and wont own up to any of his faults in life. Hollyleaf is one of my favs

by Bloodpaw December 28th 2012, 13:17

Also, Hollyleaf likes justice! Good trait in a leader, no?

by Sponsored content

Hollyleaf Debate

Do you like Hollyleaf?

Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate

Re: Hollyleaf Debate