what do you think of the tribe of rushing water?

i like them cuz they're bo$$

Meh. I don't like them.

I think they're alright, but not really my favourite. Some things I like about them, and some I don't.

I like them and their communist ways

Communist? hmm.. didn't think of it that way until now! I just viewed them as something similar to a Native American tribe.

I do not like them they are okay.

Not the best not the worst. I don't love their way of life.

I guess they are OK. I mean, not bad cats and very interesting to know something about strange cats but not the best.

In the books, the Erins made them sound like they looked funny, acted funny, and, well, lived funny. I don't think the Erins really liked them.

Well who knows, maybe she did, maybe she didn't. She probably made them seem like that because she wanted to try something NEW and DIFFERENT in the Warriors Series(?)

Maybe. New and different. Hmmmm... What about Lark and Pine?

Oh I don't like them much. Especially Stone teller. He's annoying and subtly rude.

I agree with you, Robynwing. Every time the Tribe was in the books, I was bored out of my skull and extremley annoyed. Stoneteller was annoying, mean and a selifsh dirtbag. He's even worse than Hollyleaf, and that means a lot since it's coming from me. And the tribe itself is pretty stupid too. In Moonrise, they kidnapped Stormfur and kicked out his only friends, and then they expected him to save them. Last time I checked, if you need someone to save your way of ife, you aren't supposed to make your saviour think your his enemy!
Then after Stormfur tried to help the Tribe defeat the invaders and the Tribe was too incompetent to fight, they blamed Stormfur, banished him and Stoneteller forced the Tribe to think they were dead. Brook's own brother condemed her for the plan's faliure! And doesn't it seem cruel to never let the Stoneteller out of the cave? When Crag was made Stoneteller, he wasn't happy at all; he was depressed because he would never get to see his own territory again. That's just ridculous!
The only exception would be Sign of The Moon, but I am still glad they'll never make another apperance in the books again.

Stareye wrote:I agree with you, Robynwing. Every time the Tribe was in the books, I was bored out of my skull and extremley annoyed. Stoneteller was annoying, mean and a selifsh dirtbag. He's even worse than Hollyleaf, and that means a lot since it's coming from me. And the tribe itself is pretty stupid too. In Moonrise, they kidnapped Stormfur and kicked out his only friends, and then they expected him to save them. Last time I checked, if you need someone to save your way of ife, you aren't supposed to make your saviour think your his enemy!
Then after Stormfur tried to help the Tribe defeat the invaders and the Tribe was too incompetent to fight, they blamed Stormfur, banished him and Stoneteller forced the Tribe to think they were dead. Brook's own brother condemed her for the plan's faliure! And doesn't it seem cruel to never let the Stoneteller out of the cave? When Crag was made Stoneteller, he wasn't happy at all; he was depressed because he would never get to see his own territory again. That's just ridculous!
The only exception would be Sign of The Moon, but I am still glad they'll never make another apperance in the books again.

YUSH! Someone who agrees with me!! And you'd think since it was kinda there fault that Feathertail died, that they would be WAY nicer to Stormfur. But nooooo.

Stareye and Robynwing- While I don't hate all members of the Tribe, and the idea of including a non-Warrior Clan culture interesting, I kind of have to agree with you.

Well, I didn't really enjoy their part of the book, and found them quite...boring, to say. Unentertaining to say the least. I think their culture is ...slightly...harsh? I mean, not letting the Stoneteller out of the cave? That's...wow...I'd hate that, to be honest. XDD I only really liked Brook from the tribe. :/

I like the tribe. Their way of life offered an interesting look at the way different cats have survived. The Tribe has had more problems than the Clans, and its no suprise they panic whenever something happens. I wish the Erins would write a book on the Tribe like they did with SkyClan.

Xenialhaze wrote:Well, I didn't really enjoy their part of the book, and found them quite...boring, to say. Unentertaining to say the least. I think their culture is ...slightly...harsh? I mean, not letting the Stoneteller out of the cave? That's...wow...I'd hate that, to be honest. XDD I only really liked Brook from the tribe. :/

harsh as in communist xP

Iceshadow wrote:I like the tribe. Their way of life offered an interesting look at the way different cats have survived. The Tribe has had more problems than the Clans, and its no suprise they panic whenever something happens. I wish the Erins would write a book on the Tribe like they did with SkyClan.

yes the tribe is interesting because it offers a new perspective on how cats live!

I agree with Dragonmeteor we can see how cats live in a different way

I like the tribe!! I think they're quite interesting

Goldenstream wrote:I like the tribe!! I think they're quite interesting

Yeah me too Goldy! I think they are coolio and different

I like that their names sound cool.

I think that it makes things more interesting!

The name "Tribe" makes it sound less sophisticated and more primitive

"Clan" sounds much more professional