What is the best WindClan cat in the books?

What is the best WindClan cat in the books?

If you ask me, there's no such thing; everyone has diffrent opinions.
But in my opinion, it would have to be Heathertail. I mean, let's face it, a lot of majour WindClan characters are nasty jerks. Once Onestar became leader, he led an ambush to try and drive ThunderClan out. Crowfeather is obnixous, rude, and he neglects his family. Breezepelt is every bit as obnixous and rude as his father, and on top of that he's a physcotic murderer. Mudclaw basically betrayed his clan by starting up a rebellion and tried to kill his own future leader. And Tallstar.. he isn't bad at all, but he relied a little too much on Firestar and his ThunderClan allies.
Heathertail was a sweet and kind apprentice before she started seeing Lionblaze, but once he broke it off, she was still loyal to her clan, and she never betrayed Lionblaze either. (Who was more likely to spill the beans about the tunnel? A loose-lipped kit who has no sense of how important the secret was, or an apprentice who still loved Lionblaze at the time?) And it turns out that Heathertail isn't a dependant whiner like some other stereotypes; after awhile she got over it and became an independent warrior. And to add to the loyalty card, she never tried to kill her own leader or went on a murder rampage.

Hmm, I think you're right Stareye! Heathertail would be the better of WindClan cats in the books. What about...what's her name...Whitetail?

I guess she's okay.. but we really haven't seen that much of her.

That's true I guess.

who was the leader at the beginning of the books? longtail? longstar I think. he was bo$$

When Firepaw joined.....it was Tallstar. At the very, very beginning, it was Windstar.


Don't forget now, guys. Heathertail hates Lionblaze now and wants to kill him?

Brightstar-Yeah, that's why I wasn't so sure if Heathertail is the 'best'. I know, how about Graywing the Wise! He's like the Sun Tzu of the warrior clan cat world. A Master strategist.

Honeytongue wrote:Brightstar-Yeah, that's why I wasn't so sure if Heathertail is the 'best'. I know, how about Graywing the Wise! He's like the Sun Tzu of the warrior clan cat world. A Master strategist.

Julius Caesar?

Tobi wrote:

Julius Caesar?

@Honeytongue: What Tobi means is that Julius was a master Roman war strategist. His methods of fighting are still examined and put to use today. Guess what I read?

Brightstar wrote: When Firepaw joined.....it was Tallstar. At the very, very beginning, it was Windstar.


Don't forget now, guys. Heathertail hates Lionblaze now and wants to kill him?

And during Bluestar's Prophecy, it was Heatherstar.
I don't think Heathertail actullay wants to kill Lionblaze. Sure, she hates his guts, but she's never shown any sign of wanting Lionblaze dead.

I think WindClan cats are all the best

LOL Owlflight, but everyone has their own opinion. I havent read all the books but I think that Onestar is the best Windclan cat not because he is leader and all but becuase he is fair and smart, and he can make great desicons. Like, sure, sometimes he can be very.... Fast sometimes, but he makes friends with other clan cats to get to know them better but not like good bffs. But thats just from what Ive read so far...

SEDGEWHISKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I still think Heathertail betrayed Lionblaze because at that time she sisn't love him anymore (cause he ditched her ) and would the clan really believe in a kit's tale?

I don't have any particular favorite...... I guess maybe Ashfoot? I don't know.

I like Crowfeather! He remind me of me!

AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO LOVES CROWFEATHER!?!?!?!

hmm i dot really know i mean Heathertail is Okay but so is Ashfoot, Ashfoot never did anything bad that i can think of... i really dont know... my opinion is...Oooooooo idea
GREYPOOL AND WILLOWBREEZE they r WindClan and Silverstream and Feathertail and Stormfur.

Crowfeather

I also would say, Tallstar, cuz he was Ok

Coyoteheart wrote:AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO LOVES CROWFEATHER!?!?!?!

No! I like him too

I wonder if there's any Kesterlwing fans out there? As far as I know, no Warriors fan cares about him at all.

Crowfeather is awesome!

I like Sunstrike, even though she hasnt really been seen in the books.