Is Firestar really that good?

First topic message reminder :

This may sound weird but I don't even like Firestar

He was pretty cool as apprentice/deputy/warrior, but when he became leader he went so downhill. He gave territory to ShadowClan, let kittypets into ThunderClan, and butted into WindClan's business StarClan knows how many times. So I guess I'm kind of for Firestar to die so we can see the era of Bramblestar!

Oh hi, Insert Name Here. They could at least use someone elses family for main character.

The name is Fireheart and that is true but I guess Erin doesn't want it that way...

She (they)needs creativity, insert name here.

Maplestream... be quiet. That's all I can say. Stop calling Fireheart "Insert-name here", okay?

Brightstar, I wouldn't really consider that spam. ^-^ Anyways, please Maplestream don't do one word posts and call me Fireheart, not Insert Name Here.

Fine. anyways, have you noticed that in each seres the main character(one of them) falls in love illegally?Ex, Firestar-Spottedleaf, Leafpool-crowfeather, Lionblaze-Heathertail, Dovewing-tigerheart.

It's exciting that way

they could at least break the warrior code a different way, though! like Tigerheart Eats all the prey before everyone else.

Shadowstorm wrote:This may sound weird but I don't even like Firestar

He was pretty cool as apprentice/deputy/warrior, but when he became leader he went so downhill. He gave territory to ShadowClan, let kittypets into ThunderClan, and butted into WindClan's business StarClan knows how many times. So I guess I'm kind of for Firestar to die so we can see the era of Bramblestar!

Yeah he's not that good

My name is FIREHEART, so do you all not like me? (jk, I know you all like me.....right?! O.o) Anyways, even though my username is Fireheart, and do kind of like him as a "hero" but he DOES have to go. ^-^

Firestar isn't one of my most favorites, but he's pretty cool. 20.Purrcent.Cooler. :33 Of course, we all have our opinions, right? Some may be diffurent from mine, and I'm down with that. XDD

Meh, I'll say what I think here:

In the first series I generally liked Firestar. He was a carefree Kittypet who was offered the chance to join ThunderClan by Bluestar alongside Graypaw (Graystripe) and Lionheart. He soon became an apprentice and then a warrior. And eventually deputy and then, leader.

However, as the series have gone along I have started to dislike Firestar. Mainly because he got involved in WindClan's business a lot and allowed Loners like Daisy and Purdy, even former Kittypets like Millie into the Clan.

So... yeah... I think his time has come and in The Last Hope's release we may see him join the ranks of StarClan.

I don't want Firestar to die, I just believe its time for him to move on.

Silverbreeze wrote:Meh, I'll say what I think here:

In the first series I generally liked Firestar. He was a carefree Kittypet who was offered the chance to join ThunderClan by Bluestar alongside Graypaw (Graystripe) and Lionheart. He soon became an apprentice and then a warrior. And eventually deputy and then, leader.

However, as the series have gone along I have started to dislike Firestar. Mainly because he got involved in WindClan's business a lot and allowed Loners like Daisy and Purdy, even former Kittypets like Millie into the Clan.

So... yeah... I think his time has come and in The Last Hope's release we may see him join the ranks of StarClan.

I don't want Firestar to die, I just believe its time for him to move on.

I understand completely on what you mean! I guess that's what most people think too though. I can tell that you might want him to die nobly in battle? (I could be wrong, just a guess).

:33 << It IS what I want to happen. A noble leader should have a noble death...am I right? o3o XDD

Fireheart wrote:I can tell that you might want him to die nobly in battle?

Yeah, I'd like him to die nobly in battle like a true Warrior. If that's not what happens, then death by old age is what I think will happen to him.

But hey, he may never die at all.

Maybe he'l die cause a pencil fell on his head. ((lol Fireheart! Everyone wants you to die! jk))

May never die at all? You could be right on that one but who knows, I guess we have to wait for what Erin has in-stored for us? Oh, and Silverstar, your mean! ^-^ (jk)

:33<< Firestar doesn't die. He's secretly immortal! His weakness is one thing...a feather. We need FEATHERS!

:33 << Though in all seriousness, let's hope he dies a good noble death...not an object falling on his head...well...actually..that would be hilarious. XDD Just sayin'.

*Drops a pencil on Firestar's head* o3o

Yeah, the Erin's probably have something big in stored for all of the Warriors fans. We'll just have to wait and see what happens. :3

Maybe all this suspense and hating on Firestar is what she wants us to do! O.o

:33 << Waiting and seeing is boring though...let's keep making up deaths! XDD

:33<< By the way... *Gives Fireheart some respect* Don't lose it please. XDD Yes, I'm taking this very seriously.

Huh? hahaaha, now I am confused but, okay?

Fireheart wrote:Maybe all this suspense and hating on Firestar is what she wants us to do! O.o

:O *Whacks Erin with pencil* Why Erin? WHY? (JK, lol)

YES! THE POWER OF THE PENCIL!! lol.

:33 << Basically speaking, I respect you.

>:33 << Also Silver, beclaws she can.

(I'm gettin' in the nasty habit of adding :33 << to the beginning of my post again. DDX)