Is Firestar really that good?

First topic message reminder :

This may sound weird but I don't even like Firestar

He was pretty cool as apprentice/deputy/warrior, but when he became leader he went so downhill. He gave territory to ShadowClan, let kittypets into ThunderClan, and butted into WindClan's business StarClan knows how many times. So I guess I'm kind of for Firestar to die so we can see the era of Bramblestar!

Id have to agree. I dislike FireStar. In my opinion they could have done WAY better~

Xenialhaze: Because i can.. what? Im confused.

Hahaha, I can tell. ^-^ I see it in ALL of your posts although, its no bother at all.

:33 << Yay. ^w^ Also, yeah I tend to confuse people like that. Sorry. ^^;

No apologies needed, honestly. I tend to use "^-^" a lot, so I guess we both are addicted to those things. ^-^

Me and Xenail on another Forum both use :33's alot. Along with this forum :33

Hahaha, so it seems. Anyways, back on topic?

FeatherPelt wrote:Me and Xenail on another Forum both use :33's alot. Along with this forum :33

:33 << You have no idea where I got this and 38) from do you?

:33 << I agree, back ontopic.

:33<< *Insert how awesome Firestar is...XDD?*

Well, is he awesome in any way?!?!?! O.o

:33 << Like most people on this topic said, when he started out he was pretty awesome. 20% cooler to be exact. Now...well...meh...not as...cool..

But even in the present books, what is good things about him? (if there is anything)

He was ok, in the begining but he kinda lost it near the end.

I agree. I had some respect for him in the beginning but now, that respect is almost completely gone.

Meh, the respect I used to have for him is almost completely gone.

I still sort of respect and like him. :3

Exactly, I mean, why else would we want him to at least die Nobly in battle?

:33 << He's not all that bad. He's just....nicer...^^;

Too nice is all I can say.

Too willing to allow outsiders into his Clan is more like it.

And Too Nice to help Windclan with all their problems as well.

Next thing you know he'll be allowing non-cats to become warriors! I saw a fan-fic about how two young badgers join ThunderClan [it's pretty cool].

Badgers?! That is very strange...that gets me thinking now...hmm...*runs to a topic*

*Looks at Honeystar's post* Hmm... *Imagines Firestar allowing a fox to join ThunderClan, XD*

:33 << *Imagining Firestar allowing a Mouse to join.* Awesomeness. o3o

That would be very strange! What about an eagle?! O.o

:33 << Well, if the eagle was willing that'd sure give them advantages,eh?