Which Cat is The Best Evil Cat in Warriors?

It's a poll! Which cat do you think was the best baddest, evil cat in the Warriors series? Justify your reasoning.

This is based on how well you like the cat as a villian. Which cat had the best plans? Which cat was most evil?

Vote canceling is enabled, so if one person posts their opinion and you find their opinion good, you can change your vote

Scoruge, was the evilest cat. I mean, he tried to take over the whole forest. And he killed Tigerstar without mercy.

Tigerstar. He was a blood-thirsty cat and very ambitious in being feared and being the boss.

I quite liked Scourge A little cat who's the neighbourhood bad dude. Though Brokenstar was a good villain as well, he didn't have as much depth to me. Sure the Erins included his history with his spoiled kithood and ignorant father but he didn't seem to have many other feelings except hatred. Scourge showed some emotions when taking decisions for his Clan, and when they were threatened, he killed when necessary. He didn't just go around eliminating his competition because he was bored or simply wanted a change of position.

Scourge! So tiny and evil

I think Brokenstar, because he was an evil maniac the moment he was born (As said in "Secret of the Clans") Here is why the others don't work:

Scourge: He started out as a runt, then a hero, THEN a murderous cat. And somehow he converted.

Tigerstar: His evilness was inherited from his mentor, Thistleclaw.

Hawkfrost: His evilness was inherited from his father, Tigerstar.

Firestar: You've got to be kidding me.

I agree with Mist. I think Brokenstar was the most evil. He was evil in the start, when he was just born to Yellowfang. And yeah, Tigerstar wouldn't have been evil if it hadn't been for Thistleclaw. Scourge wouldn't have been evil if it weren't for Tigerstar. And Firestar........ O.o

Scourge...DEFINITELY he was sooo mean. I kinda felt sorry for him in the beginning but, he turned into a total jerk (and murderer) later.

I think i would have to vote Tigerstar for the most evil. I mean even from the first chapters of into the wild he plotted his take over of Thunderclan. He starts by murdering Redtail and then follows by killing Oakheart immediately afterwards to create his cover story. Then went on to injure and terrify his apprentice into lying and going along with Tigerstar's cover story. He made a very cruel, snide and unforgiving mentor to Ravenpaw. Even though to the readers, it was very obvious that he played the antagonist, he was very skilled at hiding it from most of his clanmates. I think to me that was what was most disturbing about the character. He was ruthless when it came to removing those in his way of power. If i remember right he was in one way or another responsible for the death of Lionheart and then later he led the wild dogs to thunderclan by sacrificing Brindleface to give them a taste for cats blood. Then that lead to the death of Swiftpaw and the brutal mauling of Brightpaw as well. Then there was the fact that it was he who tried to murder Bluestar while the clan was busy in battle which failed due to Fireheart. But unfortunately, Bluestar ended up sacrificing the last of her lives to save her clan from the dog packs. And i know this is back tracking a bit i think but there was also his ability to convince others to follow him. Like Darkstripe for example who became thoroughly convinced that Tigerstar was the only one in the forest worth following then when it came to both of their deaths and they wandered the Dark Forest, Darkstripe was scared and asked to travel with Tigerstar who refused him then. I just find that to me at least the who concept behind the character of Tigerstar was very elaborate and well planned out. He created a lot of the suspense at the beginning of the series.

I have to say it would Tigerstar as well. Scourge, like CheeseStar, said, actually cared for his Clan sometimes. He kills when necessary and doesn't ruthlessly kill like Tigerstar does. Hawkfrost was alright, except he was basically a pawn of his father. Firestar wasn't really evil at all. He just got boring after awhile.

Maybe that's the point. In entertainment terms, Firestar is a villain! I'd have to say Scourge. Not only is he a evil and fearsome that is truly rare in fantasy, he really does care about his clan. Why did he want a share of the forest in the first place? So BloodClan would have a more hospitable home with more than enough food to go around. Sure, he could have easily done it without Tigerstar's help, since they almost won the battle on their own, so why did he accept his partnership? Well, okay, besides the opportunity to kill Tigerstar in his sleep. ( ) Maybe because with the extra forces, there would be less risk to his own cats dying..?

Hawkfrost ^^ He seemed very evil to me.

I voted Firestar. He is arrogant, seems nice, but wants to brainwash all cats.

Tigerclaw or Scourge... both very bloodthirsty.

I voted for Brokenstar.

All the other cats weren't born with blood lust like Brokenstar was.

Thistleclaw corrupted Tigerstar, who ended up turning Scourge evil and Hawkfrost as well.
So really it was a chain reaction between all the other evil kitties, but Brokenstar was the only one who went as far as to murder his own father, kill his own apprentice, kill his cousins, drive the elders from camp, and force his clan into needless blood-shed and not to mention he FORCED kits to fight to their deaths and wasn't even sorry for them or their families.

Um tigerstar didn't actually have anything to do with scourge being evil. Scourge was born as a runt if I remember and was always fighting to be the top. Tigerstar had no role in MAKING scourge evil. So far as anyone can really be sure, scourge was always evil. Tigerstar was simply responsible for introducing scourges characters in the book and bringing blood clan out of twolegs place and bringing them to the forest where they then decided to try to take over the clans.

I think Hawkfrost was evil in the first place. Or maybe it was resentment at other cats that made him an easy victim for Tigerstar's promises. I bet his Clanmates still viewed him as Tigerstar's son, the way they saw Brambleclaw.


But I voted Firestar. Just for kicks.

Scourge! Reasons:
1.He looks like a cutie!
2.He kills dog, cats, kittypets.
3.HES A CRAZY CAT WHO KILLED TIGERSTAR AND FIRESTAR!
4.MEOW! (The sound of a VICTIM)
5.TINY! !

Scourge didn't kill Firestar. He took one of his nine lives but Firestar didn't truly die until much later.

Silverwing wrote:Um tigerstar didn't actually have anything to do with scourge being evil. Scourge was born as a runt if I remember and was always fighting to be the top. Tigerstar had no role in MAKING scourge evil. So far as anyone can really be sure, scourge was always evil. Tigerstar was simply responsible for introducing scourges characters in the book and bringing blood clan out of twolegs place and bringing them to the forest where they then decided to try to take over the clans.

Well...

Tigerpaw did make fun of Scourge, which kind of started flames out of a spark.

I think Brokenstar is most evil too, because he was born evil from the start. Nobody really made him turn, so yea

I went with Firestar.
You know why?
None of the cats you mentioned are actually evil.
They still have emotions and feelings and are still human( Cat, you know what i mean.)
Firestar potrayed these cats as cold hearted, evil beings with no feelings for love and friendship. He didnt try to talk with these "evil" cats or coax them out of it. He went straight for the witch burning routine.
And maybe that was the author,s point. To show that no cat(person) is perfect and still have thier flaws.
But without flaws where would we be?
It would be a boring and a pointless life.
Firestar in he end could be considered as bad as the rest of them.
Thats my opinion on the matter!

Sorry about that Brightfrost. I knew he only took one life.