Which cat do you want as the new Thunderclan leader??

First topic message reminder :

This is for the books guys, not the Clans here on the site

Vote-canceling is activated, so if you guys ever change your opinions after you've read a new book, you can change your votes

I choose Brambleclaw. After all he's been through, I definitely think he deserves to be Leader. He proved himself worthy of Deputyship, and was made Deputy, so he's the rightwise Leader of Thunderclan. And it wouldn't exactly be fair if someone else was made Leader, because they were never Deputy.

But that happened when Tigerclaw was Bluestar's deputy too. He was never made leader of Thunderclan and someone else that was never deputy was made leader.

True, true. But do you believe Brambleclaw would do that? I don't.

I'm not up to date on the series. I just wanted to make a point.

Oh, okay. lol! What book are you on?

I haven't read them in years. Last thing I remember....Hollykit was about to tell her brothers about the prophecy she got in her dream. It was her first one I think.

Oh...Sorry for ruining it! Just forget everything! Firestar is leader!

Lol I already know and I have no idea when I am going to have time to pick it back up.

Lol, keep reading-it gets really good. And I feel mean for saying this, but I hope Squirrelflight dies because I don't really like her as deputy.
Phoenix- lol, wowwwwwww XD I doubt Jayfeather would do that though!

i voted Graystripe. I don't think he's THAT old, since he's not even in the elders den yet. Besides, he has more experience than any other cat, was born in the forest, and was Firestar's first friend to make. And Firestar was known as Rusty, the kittypet, at the time. So, i think Graystripe would be a good leader.

Swiftheart, although this is not stated in the rules, posting on topics that are more than 2 weeks inactive cannot be posted on. Sorry :3 Try to remember next time!!!! >

sorry. hehe. I will try to remember next time. I did mean what i posted though.

I was thinking that maybe the rule should be lifted for warriors discussions too. People love to put their opinion in and they are endlessly debatable. Especially when new members want to join them, but they can't. New topics would just be considered rip offs of the original. These are just my thoughts.

I agree with you.

Swiftheart, minimum words in the post is 3. Remember next time

I agree, Cheesestar. To input my own opinion, I think debates should not apply. But then again, we can't bring up every single old debate.

I would say Brambleclaw he seems to be very good fitting for that. He is a loyal warrior and fight well for his clan, I have only read A new prophecy so I don't know if there might come other cats later on who might fit better than him. But graystripe is Also a good oppinion, a loyal warrior ready to do anything for his clan, and at the same time he us wise.
Now when I think about it, I would say Graystripe, even through he is already Deputy.

Blueeye, please don't post on topics (excluding character sheets and art galleries) that have a 14 day gap between the last post and the current date. This helps reduce the flow of spam. Thanks

Okay, this is ridiculous! These old topics keep getting brought back up by new members who don't usually understand the rules yet, and there further bumped up by people reminding them not to bump old topics, and when people open new topics for the same subject it just clutters up the forum! We need a better system!

I say that that Redtail and lionheart should have not died. but mostly i say That Redtail should be leader if he didnt die.

I say Thornclaw! He is so smart and fun. He can be serious at times. (Such as when he found out about the dogs in ThunderClan territory)

Whitestorm, 100%. I always respected him; his wisdom, courage, faith, there was little I didn't admire about him. He respected everybody's thoughts, whether he agreed with them or not, and found the logic in everything. I was sad when he died. I wish Firestar died instead. >.<

( I think the not-to-post-on-topics-that-have-not-been-posted-on-for-two-weeks rule doesn't apply for warrior cat discussions )

I agree with Torrentheart. Whitestorm was one of my all time favourite ThunderClan cats. He's strong, wise, experienced and a great advisor and leader. But he was actually pretty old then so he couldn't have lived that long as a leader :/

Lionheart is somewhat like Whitestorm but younger. He was caring, smart and kind and he would have made a better leader since he was quite young but sadly he died.

Hmm... I choose Lionheart and agree with Frost. Whitestorm would've been my choice for sure if he hadn't been so old. /:

I think Graystripe would've been a great leader, along with Whitestorm. I'm mad at the Erin Hunters for making Whitestorm die. Whitestar and Graystar are both really boring names, but who cares?

I think Brambleclaw would be the logical answer to this question.  He was the deputy of Firestar, and he was a good one too