why did tigerclaw really hate fireheart that much?

First topic message reminder :

Why did the then tigerclaw hate fireheart that much?

I think he has nearly all of his lives. 6 or 7 I believe
o.O

Well, he got one lost when a tree fell on him, another in the Greencough epidemic, any pothers you can think of??

Icestar wrote:Well, he got one lost when a tree fell on him, another in the Greencough epidemic, any pothers you can think of??

Lost one when fighting Scourge (funny how I typed Pain by accident before I caught my mistake)

Didn't he also give some to Squirrelflight???

Give lives to Squirrelflight??? I dont think thats possible...

Well, Tigerstar's father left the clan to become a kittypet, so he has good reason to hate kittypets.

Stareye wrote:Well, Tigerstar's father left the clan to become a kittypet, so he has good reason to hate kittypets.

WHAT? where does it say that?!! in which book?!?!

It's in 'Bluestar's Prophecy' one of the Special Edition books.

Oh yeah, and Tigerstar's father was Pinestar, ThunderClan's Leader.

wow. was Pinestar was evil?

I don't think so.

isnt tigerstar's mate Sasha?

Tigerstar had two mates! Goldenflower (mother of Brambleclaw and Tawnypelt) was his mate in ThunderClan. Sasha (mother of Hawkfrost, Mothwing, and Tadpole), former Kittypet turned Loner, was Tigerstar's secret mate when he was ShadowClan's Leader.

Tigerclaw wasnt always bad. It was his mentor, Bristleclaw's, fault. He was taught by a dark forest warrior and passed down the evil that was in him, to Tigerclaw. Sometimes, there just not any hope when someone teaches you something when your young. it becomes a habit. Although, I'm not saying that he isnt horrible. He is. I see NO reason that he should try and murder Bluestar. Even if he wanted to be leader.

and by the way... how do you earn reputation points?

Oh..... Warrior, people have to "Thumbs Up" your post. haha. You can't do it yourself.

WarriorHawkPath wrote:Tigerclaw wasnt always bad. It was his mentor, Bristleclaw's, fault. He was taught by a dark forest warrior and passed down the evil that was in him, to Tigerclaw. Sometimes, there just not any hope when someone teaches you something when your young. it becomes a habit. Although, I'm not saying that he isnt horrible. He is. I see NO reason that he should try and murder Bluestar. Even if he wanted to be leader.

umm... isn't it Thistleclaw? and i can understand why Pinestar might have wanted to be a kittypet. if you were a manager of a stressful, busy company wouldn't you love to give it up to be pampered and spoiled? (okay, maybe i wouldn't want to be spoiled but you get the idea).

Why would you want to be a kittypet if you were a leader and was a head and in control.

Well, that was pinestar's decision.