why did tigerclaw really hate fireheart that much?

First topic message reminder :

Why did the then tigerclaw hate fireheart that much?

CheeseStar wrote:yeah ravenpaw knew the truth (that tigerclaw killed the deputy to become the deputy) so he told firepaw. then, firepaw had it out for tigerclaw. after that, firepaw kept accidentally seeing some of his plans, and reporting them to bluestar. then, it was because of firepaw that tigerclaw got kicked out of thunderclan.

actually when I was reading the book, I thought Tigerclaw killed Lionheart too. I thought that the truth would be revealed later. It would so evil if tigerclaw killed lionheart too

Tigerclaw tried to kill Bluestar, which was even worse. He also tried to kill Fireheart, like, what? 10 times?

Silverrain wrote:

actually when I was reading the book, I thought Tigerclaw killed Lionheart too. I thought that the truth would be revealed later. It would so evil if tigerclaw killed lionheart too

Yeah same here. I thought maybe during the battle where Lionheart died, Tigerclaw finished him off too. I thought maybe it would be revealed later

CheeseStar wrote:yeah ravenpaw knew the truth (that tigerclaw killed the deputy to become the deputy) so he told firepaw. then, firepaw had it out for tigerclaw. after that, firepaw kept accidentally seeing some of his plans, and reporting them to bluestar. then, it was because of firepaw that tigerclaw got kicked out of thunderclan.

I got that not something else.

CheeseStar wrote:yeah ravenpaw knew the truth (that tigerclaw killed the deputy to become the deputy) so he told firepaw. then, firepaw had it out for tigerclaw. after that, firepaw kept accidentally seeing some of his plans, and reporting them to bluestar. then, it was because of firepaw that tigerclaw got kicked out of thunderclan.

Yeah and also because Fireheart got deputy position and Tigerclaw wanted that

Shuriken, you're messed up. Fireheart became deputy AFTER Tigerclaw got exiled. And Tigerclaw had been deputy when he got exiled.

i haven't read the series since last year. and you know, we're just repeating the same points. tigerclaw killed redtail, ravenpaw knew and told firepaw, tigerclaw knew that firepaw knew, tried to kill him, ravenpaw went "missing", tigerclaw tried to kill bluestar, tigerclaw had something to do with lionheart's death, fireheart got tigerclaw exiled after he became deputy and was made deputy after that. did i miss something again? HHMMM?

Ummmm...... Tigerclaw tried to kill Fireheart?

CheeseStar wrote:i haven't read the series since last year. and you know, we're just repeating the same points. tigerclaw killed redtail, ravenpaw knew and told firepaw, tigerclaw knew that firepaw knew, tried to kill him, ravenpaw went "missing", tigerclaw tried to kill bluestar, tigerclaw had something to do with lionheart's death, fireheart got tigerclaw exiled after he became deputy and was made deputy after that. did i miss something again? HHMMM?

yes that's right there.

CheeseStar wrote:i haven't read the series since last year. and you know, we're just repeating the same points. tigerclaw killed redtail, ravenpaw knew and told firepaw, tigerclaw knew that firepaw knew, tried to kill him, ravenpaw went "missing", tigerclaw tried to kill bluestar, tigerclaw had something to do with lionheart's death, fireheart got tigerclaw exiled after he became deputy and was made deputy after that. did i miss something again? HHMMM?

What about graystripe?

Well.... tigerclaw didn't try to kill greystripe

CheeseStar wrote:i haven't read the series since last year. and you know, we're just repeating the same points. tigerclaw killed redtail, ravenpaw knew and told firepaw, tigerclaw knew that firepaw knew, tried to kill him, ravenpaw went "missing", tigerclaw tried to kill bluestar, tigerclaw had something to do with lionheart's death, fireheart got tigerclaw exiled after he became deputy and was made deputy after that. did i miss something again? HHMMM?

What about Longtail and Dustpelt?

Well, they were just Tigerclaw's followers.

In Book 6, The Last Hope, I bet Tigerclaw will go and kill Firestar first.

Max wrote:In Book 6, The Last Hope, I bet Tigerclaw will go and kill Firestar first.

But I think the 4th prophesied cat is Firestar

Sunfall wrote:

What about Longtail and Dustpelt?

wasn't it longtail and darkstripe? dustpelt was just grouchy wasn't he?

Maybe. Darkstripe was the really bad one. Longtail was loyal at the end. *shrug*

you know what? maybe tigerstar didnt like firestar because firestar was smexy enough

Weird...

Darkfire wrote:you know what? maybe tigerstar didnt like firestar because firestar was smexy enough

you wish you could be that awesome. he was just a much better warrior and more fit to run a clan. i mean, what respectful deputy wants to feed their clan rotten food (after Tigerclaw became Tigerstar, he fed the Ribver-Shadow Clan alliance crow food.)

CheeseStar wrote:

you wish you could be that awesome. he was just a much better warrior and more fit to run a clan. i mean, what respectful deputy wants to feed their clan rotten food (after Tigerclaw became Tigerstar, he fed the Ribver-Shadow Clan alliance crow food.)

what remind meh wat crow food is again?

Crow food is rotten food....half-eaten....you know.

*shivers* Yuck. So... Tigerstar and Firestar are probably both going to die for good in the battle? Is that what we're saying?

Icestar wrote:*shivers* Yuck. So... Tigerstar and Firestar are probably both going to die for good in the battle? Is that what we're saying?

I bet Tigerstar will die. That's almost for sure. Not really certain about Mr. Fireheart... from what I've seen they like to keep him alive.

True. But if the Erins know what is good for the series, Firestar will die, or lose a few lives in the battle. (Do we know how many he has left??)