Best WindClan cat

Um...what more is there to say? Please vote! I chose Tallstar because...reasons.

Tallstar because he's my father. AND ME OF COURSE

Onestar or Tallstar. Both were really awesome. Onestar was very wise and wasn't very ambitious and Tallstar was wise and strong. Both had different personalities but both were really courageous and epic

DEFINITELY Breezepelt >.> jk.
I chose Tallstar for basically the same reasons as Torrentheart (why Torry, why ;A;)

DOESPRING. I like Doespring, for some reason. I also quite like Aspenfall, Cloudrunner, and Ryestalk. Also Shrewclaw. He makes me laugh! ( and cry)

Tallstar. Almost everyone else was stupid at some point (Or points) in time. Breezepelt, Crowfeather, Onestar... etc.

Tallstar was an epic leader... I was so sad when he died. 

Isn't it obvious?? TALLSTAR!! Then onestar. I almost cried when he died

I don't exactly like Onestar much but I agree that Tallstar was the best WindClan leader ever. He's wise and reasonable. He always puts his Clan first too.

I think Tallstar is the best Windclan cat he is wise and noble Onestar was nice when he was a warrior but once he became leader he became selfish   

I liked Onewhisker, but not Onestar. Before he became leader

SPOILERRR!!:

After he became leader, he'd never do that. I hate it when the cats go through major personality changes when nothing that traumatising has happened to them.

Awesome post Stormfrost.   I totally agree on that. Onestar practically became Firestar's enemy after he became leader.

Well .. let's see ... 

Tallstar is probably my favorite WindClan cat of all time because he's wise, and actually hates fighting.

Spoiler:

besides Frostbite , and for some strange reason, Crowfeather's pretty cool ... and stuff .... c:

Sunburn wrote:besides Frostbite

wait, who's Frostbite?

WE MUST NOT GO OFFTOPIC c:


But back to your question: She's my second account, a WindClan Warrior

Woohoo!!! Tallstar for the win!!!

Onestar is an idiot. I mean, Tallstar's all, "Onewhisker, I choose you because I know that you will walk side by side with Firestar and stuff." But what does he do?

Spoiler:

Basically, that's what the the books imply that he's thinking.

Crowfeather is okay. But he doesn't have to be so cold to Leafpool

Spoiler:

I'm not saying he's mean to her, just that he's not exactly nice. But he's in the clear with me because

Spoiler:

Breezepelt is one of my least favorite.

Spoiler:

Nightcloud is always jealous of Leafpool. And she motivates Breezepelt to hate Crowfeather.

Ashfoot is cool. Like Caraway, I like female characters who kick butt.

Heathertail didn't have to make such a big deal about Lionblaze following the warrior code.

All the others I consider okay. :3

I always really liked Tallstar since he always seemed to be a wise leader for WindClan and they were allies with the main character in the book then. After he died the alliance thing was just completely gone and I felt like it threw everything off in the books.

Let's just say that Tallstar's death completely messed up WindClan for the rest of the series, shall we? :/
Rebellion against Onestar as leader, alliance with ThunderClan shattered, yep. Poor WindClan.

Don't forget that Tallstar was already really old, in fact, ancient for a cat

I think all of us can agree that Tallstar was a great leader!

yep that's definitely true
  

Tallstar is definitely one of my favorites. I mean, come on, who can't relate to that feeling that the whole world is against you? His super edition is one of the best, in my opinion.
I also agree that Onestar is really awful. I can understand that he wanted to establish that WindClan wasn't reliant on ThunderClan to help them through their problems, but that doesn't justify invading their camp in the dead of night and attempting to drive them out of their territory!

How come I'm not in the poll? clearly I'm the best windclan member

2 reasons. 1) That is a title that other have to give and 2) This is based on the books.