DawnStorm's Choices: Firestar or Crookedstar? (Edition 1)

This is the first edition of DawnStorm's choices. So, who is it you like most? Firestar or Crookedstar? Express your opinion!




From now on, I will be doing these choices every 1-2 days. They will
include two or more choices to choose from. In this series, you choose a
favorite/most (insert trait here) and express that in a post on the
thread. Credit to Rosethorn (Forestblaze) for her weekly's. Every time I make a new one, I will announce the winner of the last one in the new topic and I will ask for the last topic to be closed.

Crooked star had better judgement skills and actually went through something more believeable than Firestar. Also, I find that Crooked is way sweeter and thinks more for his Clan. Firestar was to giving and didn't assess as much about others. That's just my opinion though. Crooked star forever!!

Firestar, because he went through more and made descisions well. Crookedstar is still awesome, though.

I agree with Lighty. She took the words right out of my mouth. xD

Firestar, he's much smarter, and made a good leader!

Crookedstar is more focused and doesn't whine about his faults and problems whereas Firestar tends to try to rid himself of his past and won't own up to the fact he was once a kittypet. I just, UGH! Firestar is a stuck-up.... bleh, I dont even know.... and just think, after Crooked's sad life, he was still sweet and was a nice person whereas you'd think he'd hate the world.

Crookedstar. he faced a lot more discrimination as an apprentice, since he was actually kind of scarred for life while Firestar (Rusty then) was just a kittypet. despite his past, Crookedstar is still a great leader and doesn't take it out on others, perhaps because he doesn't want anyone else to experience his pain. Firestar leaps into decisions a lot, because he's possibly overly kind. it puts a lot of strain on his friends and his Clan, though it makes him a hero in the end.

... Well, I like Firestar better because he went through more desicions than Crookedstar. Though I began to think that he was alive TOO long and he was getting most of the credit.

Crookedstar for sure. He suffered more pain, more betrayal, and more loss. Everything that matters to Crookedstar was in StarClan (except his trusty clanmates) while Firestar still has/had a mate, kits, grandkits, and great-grandkits, and countless kin. Seriously, Erins? Did Firestar deserve all THAT? He saved ThunderClan, of course. But he was too much of a hero! And he lived WAY too long!Besides, what was he to turn ThunderClan into a soft kittypet clan? (no offense)

Crookedstar, on the other hand, had suffered much from being rejected from his mother to losing his last daughter. He had almost nothing left to live for, yet he lived. He had to face a (false) decision that would change his life. But he was betrayed! Everything was taken away from him. He had led his clan fairly. If he had lived, RiverClan wouldn't be living under the pile of bones in TigerClan. Leopardstar was too easily charmed.

Honestly, I think Firestar was boring throughout, so my vote goes for Crookedstar.

Boring, yes. I don't think it's about him being boring though, its more about his traits and actions. And, in my opinion, Crookedstar was more tolerable