Saddest Moments

First topic message reminder :

Personally, I think all the choices are sad. I Feel so sorry for Crowfeather, Crookedkit, Bluestar, Graystripe, and Mapleshade!

How was it cruel on Crowfeather's part for Feathertail to die? o.O

Feathertails death definitely. She's my favorite. </3

Gingerblaze wrote:How was it cruel on Crowfeather's part for Feathertail to die? o.O

Feathertails death definitely. She's my favorite. </3

It is cruel, but no one can ignore their own impending death, no matter how much it hurts.
Geez, depressing myself with my own words!

But think how much Crookedkit suffered! To be humiliated, shunned, and ignored or snapped at when he talked to his mother! At least Feathertail died for a meaning, and she didn't suffer, unlike Crookedkit.

rainflower shouldn't abanden crookedkit like that!what would it be like if your mother abandon you and don't care about you! rainflower don't deserve to be a mother of a leader.

For me, Rainflower's rejection of Crookedkit was more infuriating. It only made me hope that she would drown in the river. Oh, wait....
The saddest moment for me is when Williowbreeze was saying goodbye to Crookedstar before she died, and when Crookedstar woke up, two of his kits were dead. It was awful! It wasn't their time to die!

Haha. I cry every time someone says goodbye to someone else in all books, especially when they die. Willowbreeze and Crookedstar was so sad

Crookedkit was rejected by his mother. Then, Rainflower changed his name. Later still, Rainflower refused to sleep in the nursery, leaving Crookedkit on his own. WHAT KIND OF MOTHER DOES THAT JUST BECAUSE OF A DEFORMITY?

It was pretty sad when Willowbreeze said goodbye before she died. Blustar's prophecy and Crookedstar's promise were the two most saddest books in the series.

Willowbreeze: *coughs*

Crookedstar: "Willowbreeze, are you all right?"

Willowbreeze: *coughs* "no. Crookedstar, take care of our kits."

Crookedstar: "NO! WILLOWBREEZE! DON'T LEAVE, THE CLAN NEEDS YOU, I NEED YOU!"

Willowbreeze: "goodbye, Crookedstar."

Crookedstar: "NOOOOO! HANG ON, YOU WILL SURVIVE!"

Willowbreeze: *Dies*

Crookedstar: "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"

Its so sad i couldn' bear read the rest.

It really is sad book. I feel so bad for Crookedkit.

My mother would care fr me more if i got disfigured .

Yeah. I think all of these are sad, but Warriors is sad Willowbreeze's death and Crookedkit's ignorance from his mother are the most saddening for me. Feathertail's death, well, er, we ALL knew that was going to happen

Yeah I knew about it but it was still really sad.

Firestar's death was really sad too. Sandstorm was horrified.

Oh yeah, Blazey. Sandstorm's reaction was like insanity. She was flipping out! Ah....... good times, good times, lol

All the deaths execpt for Scourge's and Tigerstar'sand Bone's and Brokenstar's andThistleclaw's and allte other Dak Forest cats' death saddened me.

Tigerstar and Dark Forest