Should Firestar die?

by Nightfrost June 7th 2011, 20:05

First topic message reminder :

So...

by Skittlestream June 17th 2011, 15:42

Hey wat the heck happened to Skyclan? Firestar saved Them in Firestar's Quest, but they are never mentioned after that.

by Icestar of ShadowClan June 20th 2011, 13:46

There is a special edition, but their life really doesnt interfere with the Clan cats. Anyway, Erin Hunter is writing something on how the clans formed, so maybe something will be said about them there.

by **Caraway** June 20th 2011, 21:01

firestar should die, then brambleclaw becomes leader for like one to three more series and then he dies too and someone else who is an apprentice right now should be leader.

and nice work watershred. Thumbs Up

by Guest June 21st 2011, 11:39

Firestar should really die now.

by Guest June 21st 2011, 11:40

DIE!!!!!!!

I shall assisinate Firestar while he is sleeping.... Suspect

by Icestar of ShadowClan June 22nd 2011, 19:54

Haha. There is a rumour that

Spoiler:

But I dont believe it.

by Nightfrost June 24th 2011, 17:22

that wuld suck. I voted I don't know... I like him but I don't want him to die, but he has been living a long time,...... I REALLY DON'T KNOW!

by Goldenheart June 29th 2011, 20:37

I have love Firestar from day one, but he has been living really long. I would sorta miss him, but I think Brambleclaw would make a great leader Very Happy

by Icestar of ShadowClan July 5th 2011, 10:42

Aww, cute signature GOldenheart. I agree with respecting him, because he overcame alot to be leader, but he should die. Rocket Launcher

by **Nyx** July 5th 2011, 10:44

Yeah. Erin hunter can't favor him that much.

by Guest July 5th 2011, 10:58

Firestar should die. He's cool and all, but he's too old.

by Guest July 11th 2011, 09:45

Nightfrost wrote:So...

firestar and sandstorm should die because they've lived too long. i'd b sad to see them go but them always being around has gotten annoying

by **Nyx** July 11th 2011, 09:47

They're ALWAYS there. Hurry up, Erin Hunter, and kill those elders!

In Firestar's Quest, Firestar says, "Hey, I'm not an elder yet." It makes him sound like he was close to being an elder 3 series of books ago!"

by Guest July 18th 2011, 12:37

Hey look! Here's a Firestar poll! Let's see what I should vote.... Twisted Evil

by Fireheart July 18th 2011, 12:40

Well as I said before, maybe Erin wants Firestar to do one last thing before he departs with his clan...but idk if that would make sense. Razz

by **Nyx** July 18th 2011, 12:42

Maybe Erin Hunter will make Firestar do something awesome.

by Fireheart July 18th 2011, 12:43

Yeah, and maybe we will like him again instead of wanting him to die!

by **Caraway** July 18th 2011, 21:31

Brightstar wrote:Maybe Erin Hunter will make Firestar do something awesome.

maybe she'll (generally referring to the authors) make him die a noble death that is really awesome. o.O just a thought. but why don't the people just end the series before he dies?

by Fireheart July 18th 2011, 21:33

I think that makes more sense than what I thought, good thinking Cheesestar!

by Guest July 19th 2011, 09:17

CheeseStar wrote:

maybe she'll (generally referring to the authors) make him die a noble death that is really awesome. o.O just a thought. but why don't the people just end the series before he dies?

I shall make a poll saying how he shuld die!! going to it now!!!

by Fireheart July 19th 2011, 14:43

Alright, that's a good idea! Smile

by Guest July 19th 2011, 17:13

I think Firestar should die of green-cough. Very Happy

by SkyStar July 19th 2011, 20:42

Icestar wrote:Haha. There is a rumour that
Spoiler:
But I dont believe it.

That is likely though to happen.

by Lunarlight July 26th 2012, 06:41

Ivyshine wrote:i think it would be HILARIOUS if he died in some wimpy totally lame way like drowning in a flood or something. i mean, if you look at everything he's somehow survived, it would be a shocking twist!

lol, like the first person to go over niagara falls survived and later died because he slipped on a banana peel and bit his lip, resulting in a bad infection

by **Pinewhisker** July 26th 2012, 07:15

I think he will..

Spoiler:

by Sponsored content

Should Firestar die?

Should Firestar die?

Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?

Re: Should Firestar die?