What should've happened.

In this you could say what really should've happened to one of the cats instead of what happened.

Example (Mine):
I think Cinderpelt should've had her leg amputated. They would put a stick on her stump for a leg.

I think Berrynose shouldn't have mated with Poppyfrost. I mean, the cat he really loves

Spoiler:

I mean, really? He should've died alone.

I'm going to be honest here,

Firestar should've never entered the forest. I think it would've been interesting if the cat had a more eventful background and personality. I mean, it's kind of obvious they make a non-Clanborn cat enter the most basic Clan

i agrre with you torrent.


I say Hollyleaf shouldn't have killed Ashfur then ran away. Also i say Squirrelflight should have had her own kits instead.

I think Bluestar should've mentored Tigerstar instead. Wonder how that would've turned out. (:

Great thoughts guys! You have such good ideas!

Funny. I came across this picture not too long ago.

Just think about it. Snowfur's death pretty much set the whole plot of warriors. Thistleclaw wouldn't have been evil, Tigerstar would've never been evil, and none of the plot would've happened :O

Feathertail shouldn't have died, because the fools cats thought that the mountains will be easier than the twolegplace, and it ended up like THAT.

Why not just say that Thistleclaw never existed and our problems will be solved (:

I dont think Snowfur's death affected the way Thistleclaw taught Tigerstar.

I think Longtail shouldn't have died. He was one of my favorite characters and he just simply died of

Spoiler:

I also think Skywatcher shouldn't have died. He was just standing there, he delivered the prophecy to Firestar, then—died.

Longtail was really really old so he would have died anyways :/
He was my favourite character in the Warriors series

I think that, in order to extend the series or whatever, it'd be interesting if Brokentail had lived. What would he have done to Yellowfang and the cats around her (ahem Firestar)? The deathberries scene was pretty cool though. Epic family sacrifices and such.

Frost wrote:I dont think Snowfur's death affected the way Thistleclaw taught Tigerstar.

Well actually it did. I did some research and found out that Whitestorm's mom and dad was Thistleclaw and Snowfur. When Snowfur died Thistleclaw became evil. He used to be nicer before then.

I say that hawkfrost and mothwing belonged in the clan and should still exist.

I say all the old cats die because they're living too long. But if I had to choose something I wouldn't want Feathertail to have died away from the clans.

Hollyleaf should have been the 4th cat. D:

Either that, or Hawkfrost should still be alive, Firestar should have died earlier. That would change the whole outcome of the story

I think SkyClan should have come back to the forest/lake. That would have been really intresting. 

Tangleclaw wrote:

Frost wrote:I dont think Snowfur's death affected the way Thistleclaw taught Tigerstar.

Well actually it did. I did some research and found out that Whitestorm's mom and dad was Thistleclaw and Snowfur. When Snowfur died Thistleclaw became evil. He used to be nicer before then.

That's not true. Thistleclaw was evil because of how Tigerclaw trained him. He just became more evil when Snowfur died. He blamed it on Bluefur.

Before Snowfur died, Blurfur tried to warn Snowfur about Thistleclaw, but she just refused to listen. She thought she loved him. Then, Whitekit was born, Snowfur died, Thistleclaw was just more mean towards Bluefur.

Redleaf, Tigerclaw didn't train Thistleclaw, Thistleclaw trained Tigerclaw. Part of why Thistleclaw was evil was because he was training in the Dark Forest, and Snowfur's death also helped him become evil.