Favorite and least favorite leader?

I tried to search but I didn't find any post exactly like this C:

What leader(s) from all the book are your favorite(s) and least favorite(s)? And why?

---

Personally I think my favorite leaders were Tallstar and Bluestar (I have only read the first series and some of The New Prophecy, so I do not know if there comes some better ones later.) because i think they actually made some good decisions. They were both really fair leaders that really cared about their Clan. Of course Bluestar got her mental problems after Tigerclaw/-star betrayed her, but looking away from that, she was a really great leader. I also quite liked Crookedstar

My least favorite must be Leopardstar and Tigerstar. Tigerstar because I've always seen him as rather cowardly and I guess we can all agree that he was very power-hungry. What I hate about him is the way that he gained power.
I also disliked Leopardstar, mostly because of the way she let herself be persuaded and manipulated by Tigerstar. I understand she felt tempted by Tigerstar's promise about a united Clan with no war anymore, but fear hold her down when she learned more about Tigerstar's ambitions. She even let Stonefur be killed and didn't do anything about it - That's why I somehow dislike her :/

FAVORITE: Bluestar- I love Bluestar. It's hard to explain, but I'm like Bluestar in a lot of ways outside of WCF.

LEAST FAVORITE: Firestar- I HATE FIRESTAR. He always tried to find the peaceful way out when the rest of the clan wanted to fight! And he relieved Jayfeather of his medicine cat duties for something he didn't do JUST because he didn't want to fight! He needs to stand up for his clan for once!

I can agree about Firestar I might not directly hate him, but I see alot about what you mean. Of course I havn't gotten that far in the series, so I havn't read anything about Jayfeather yet, but already now I can see, that he is way too peaceful sometimes. Sometimes peaceful solutions are good, but just as you say, he must stand more up for his clan.

My favorite leader would be Leafstar of Skyclan
My least favorite would be Firestar and Tigerstar..

my favorite leader hmmm...... i guess leafstar and crookedstar and hailstar.

My favorite leader would be Leopardstar! I love how she is firm unlike Firestar

I like Blackstar and Leopardstar but, I HATE Firestar and Tigerstar. Tigerstar was MEAN!!

Ok....

Favorite: Leafstar, Crookedstar, Tigerstar

Least favorite: Firestar, Bluestar

My fav leader was Tallstar, he was amazing, really caring and kept the bound to thounderclan even after the defeat of Bloodclan, they both cared allot for each other. Tallstar was a good leader, a wise and fair leader!
And my least fav is Firestar, the worst leader ever named! No more to say.

Favorite leader- Tallstar
Least favorite- Firestar

My Favorites:

Crookedstar: He's a great leader, having a terrible past and all. I thought he deserved credit, and he's also my #1 fave! Like Leopardstar, he made a mistake of joining ShadowClan.

Blackstar: He was the best leader ShadowClan's had for AGES! He wasn't soft, and he has flaws.

Leafstar: The she-cat only leader to have kits when she was leader. Leafstar had to face a very hard choice. Though I'd only rate her 3/5 because she was too "soft."

Tigerstar: Though everybody says that he's "bad", I think of him as an innocent kit trained by an evil mentor and being taught that power is the only thing that matters. Everything was never his fault.

Bluestar: She was a wise and fair leader, believing in her medicine cat. You'd probably think that I'd also call her "soft", but it was a prophecy that made her do it.

Leopardstar: You may seem surprised, but I like Leopardstar. She has a flaw, and I like it that way.

Least Favorite:

Firestar: He was too perfect, always making the right decisions. He lived too long, and started the "Age of ThunderClan Kittypet Madness." He was also soft for preventing battles, for cats were given claws for a reason!

Favorite: I'd have to say, Hailstar. He may have been a minor character, but he really cared about his clan and wasn't afraid of a fight. And it was so adorable the way he helped Fallowtail on a personal level!
Least Favorite This is a tough one, but I would say it's a tie between Leopardstar and Raggedstar. Leopardstar constantly put her own clan in danger just because she;'s too proud to admit her mistakes, she acted like she owned the other clans, and she was just a complete snob. Raggedstar was an abusive, egotistical leader who only made decisions for his clan if he agreed with them, and chose to be totally blind to Brokenstar's faults. That, and did you see his reaction to Cedarstar's death? "Oh, great! I am leader now! Let's go get my nine lives, Yellowfang!"
"But don't you think you should respe-"
"Did I ask you, you mousebrained pile of foxdung?!"
Ugh....

(sorry. forgot to post this)
least fav is raggedstar. i just think that he's abit ambsive (like stareye said).
and leapaordstar. she's a bit foolish to let tigerstar rule her clan and watch her deputy die.

My favorite would have to be Crookedstar. He faced his Clanmates' initial reaction of his disfigured face (even though he did run away for awhile. But during that time at the farm he learned that he was a true Clan cat at heart and it didn't matter that others looked down on him at first. If he worked hard enough, they would accept him for the good warrior that he was.) Crookedstar was a fine leader too, and he didn't succumb to Mapleshade's whispering about power and leading all the Clans, unlike Thistleclaw. He was loyal to Hailstar and RiverClan to the end.

My least favorite leader was Maplestar. (I think that's what he was called. If you haven't read 'Code of the Clans,' you won't know who I'm talking about.) But he was ready to reveal all of his Clan's weaknesses in hope that the other Clans would help them. But it was during hard times, so of course every Clan had to fend for themselves. Maplestar didn't want to fight for territory and prey, because he still busy grieving and wallowing in the death of his mate, Songbird. She had been killed by a ShadowClan warrior and Maplestar thought that if he led his Clan to battle, more deaths would happen. All in all, he was a coward.