Millie... ugh

Ok, I know I'm not the only one who thinks this, but Millie is horrible! Silverstream was a way better character. Millie is weak, and she's so mean to he rother kits after what happens to Briarlight!

I agree. Kits should be looked after, not critized for everything. And when ivypool was being fawned over, Blossomfall was being yelled at!

I KNOW! She was so horrible! I mean, seriously, Graystripe? Bad choice.

Just because one kit is injured doesn't mean that you should give more attention to her! She acts as if she's forgotten all about the other two!

I know! Or when she speaks to them, it's just, help your sister! Don't bother her!

Viper already made this kind of topic about Millie.

You're being unfair to her.I mean how would you feel if one of your children was crippled and your other ones kept getting in trouble.I'm not criticizing,but think about what you would do in her shoes...or paws

I agree. I mean, when Graystripe fell in love with her, she was an awesome cat. She's not doing the right thing, but everyone makes mistakes.

Thunderclaw wrote:You're being unfair to her.I mean how would you feel if one of your children was crippled and your other ones kept getting in trouble.I'm not criticizing,but think about what you would do in her shoes...or paws

I would give major attention to the crippled kit, but I wouldn't scream and ignore my other kits! I would still pay attention to them and I would NOT yell at them for doing 1 TINY thing. I HATE MILLIE.

I'm just saying,we can't down a cat that's scared her kit will die.It's wrong to me.No hard feelings right?

I think Millie is okay, I mean, if you had an injured kit, you would have to spend more time with it, right? But I get your point at the fact she spends TOO much attention at that one kit.

I can agree with that.But no cat should be turned down.

I agree with that, but she yells at Blossomfall and Bumblestripe and just puts them aside like fresh kill. What mother does that?!?! She gives her too much attention.

I agree with some of you, but instead of only looking after Briarlight, look after all of the kits!

Yes ^^^^ Exactly. Maybe if she had payed maybe 40% of attention on Briarlight, and the rest on the other kits :3

She's just worried about Briarlight, knowing she may die. If your kid was in the hospital, would you be at the hospital or your other kid's house? Exactly.

Yes but if the other kids were in the hospital, and you snapped at them or ignored them whenever they talked, would that be wrong? I understand that she would pay more attention to Briarlight, but that doesn't give her a reason to be unfair.

I totally agree. She just forgot she had any other kits!

Thunderclaw wrote:You're being unfair to her.I mean how would you feel if one of your children was crippled and your other ones kept getting in trouble.I'm not criticizing,but think about what you would do in her shoes...or paws

Somehow I agree with you.

Yes, but even when they weren't in trouble she either ignored them or criticize them! And when Briarlight was out in the open and wanted to go farther, even though Bumblestripe tried to stop her, Millie still accused Bumblestripe of putting his sister in danger! A mother should be fair, kind, and loving, not accusing!

I agree with everyone. I agree most mothers would pay attention to the wounded one, but I also agree with how she ignores and accuses the others! That's why I hate her.

Yes, I totally agree. She is just as bad as Tigerstar... In a way.

@Sunbeam: Exactly!!!!


Also, Briarlight didnt want special attention. It probably hurt her more.

*Sigh* I've had my fill on this debate on many other forums, and now it's starting to catch on here.
I don't mean any offense when I say this, but I think you're being extremely unfair towards Millie. When she was a kittypet, she was without a doubt, the most bubble gummy, happiest character in the entire series. She grew up in a world completley absent of death, tragedy, or hardship. Even after she left with Graystripe and witnessed clan life firsthand, she never understood how hard their lives could be. So when all of the sudden, when Briarlight became permantley paralyzed, the toughest thing in her life she ever had to go through, she had no reserves or experience to know how to deal with it, leading to the Millie we have today. If she was born into ThunderClan, she probably would have dealed with the situation a whole lot better, but that's just not the case. Oh, and with that scene in SOTM where Millie yelled at Blossomfall for going missing, quite frankly, I agree with her. She deserved it. She deilbrately defied her leader's orders, neglected her responcibility to feed the clan, just to put her own and another warriors life at risk, for no good reason at all. In fact, I think they both got off way too easy. They should have been demoted to apprentice status for half a year. But no, order and discipline doesn't mean anything in the new generation of the clans.

Well yeah, thats been going on for forever! But, you know, "bubblegummy" characters are annoying anyways, and then shes all mean? I mean, seriously?! Does she have multiple personalities or something?