If each Clan had to go through the Great Journey again by themselves, who would survive the best?

If the Clans in the books had to endure the Great Journey again, each Clan by itself, who would you think would survive the best? (Like in food supply, health, staying strong, choosing the right routes, etc.) Keep in mind each Clan's strengths and weaknesses!

ThunderClan:
-Is not used to feeling the open force of the wind
-More trusting, and not afraid to accept others' help
-Hunting skills may help them find prey
-High moral

RiverClan:
-Thick fur
-Able to fish in streams they might come across
-Mediocre land hunting skills
-Sometimes a little too prideful to accept help

ShadowClan:
-Long fur
-Is not too picky on what food they come across
-Not used to feeling the open wind
-Usually too prideful to accept help

WindClan:
-Short fur
-Used to feeling the open wind
-Experience in large birds and rabbits
-Is not used to the wet or the cold

I believe its ThunderClan. If they can thrive in undergrowth, navigating through forest would be as easy as climbing a tree. They are not afraid to ask for help and this is a huge benefit for ThunderClan Cats. Good hunting skills means a high chance of survival.

ThunderClan it is!

But half the time the Clans are inn the snowy mountains remember. There's practically no trees up there.

Ordinarily, I would say Windclan, as they were the most suited to mountainous Terrain, but since they were so weak, and had suffered the most, I doubt they could have made it. Because of this I'm going to say thunderclan, as they would have accepted help from the tribe. Without the tribe's help, though, I also don't think they would have made it through the mountains.

Well, WindClan would probably be used to the windy terrain, but they aren't as strong as ThunderClan or RiverClan or ShadowClan. I'm going to say ThunderClan, not just agreeing with Phantom and Sunbeam, but my own experience. ThunderClan cats were complaining the least when they were journeying. Also, they are strong and they would welcome help, Purdy was there on the journey to help the Tribe, and they would let the Tribe help them.

That's my rant

I would really, honestly like to say ShadowClan. They are tough and independent, which makes them travel faster without having to lug along other cats. It might be great to have help, but that means more mouths to feed and more rest. Plus, ShadowClan cats are used to tough conditions and aren't picky about luxuries like places to sleep or food.

Yeah, I agree with CheeseStar. ShadowClan is used to not having the best stuff, so it'd be easier for them to eat anything and stuff. Plus they're probably the best fighters (in my opinion).

True true. :O I would either say RiverClan or ShadowClan. They both have relatively long fur, and are both ranther independent. WindClan depended on ThunderClan a lot during the journey, so that would've been a problem.

First things first, I hate to be a downer here, your grammar is wrong... It should say, "Which Clan would be most successful?" But that doesn't sound right either... but that's probably because I belive that when it comes to The Great Journey, the Clans either make it or they don't.
This is quite the tough question.... all the Clans would certainly find some hardships that the others would handle with ease. But if I had to choose, I think RiverClan would defintley go through the toughest journey. They couldn't rely on stumbling across wetland areas or rivers every day, so they would have to adapt fast to catching land prey or face starving.

It depends. If this actually happened in the books, it would definitely be Thunderclan, because they're the main characters and favoured by the authors.

After that, I would say Windclan because they're more used to the wind and hills.