Why does everyone Love Spottedleaf? I don't understand...

She is darn annoying. She died in the first book, why is she in every series?!?! She always seems to squeeze her way in to every series! And almost every S.E she is somehow in it. BP (I know, I know, she was alive. Still I hate her.) Firestar's Quest (LIKE SERIOUSLY YOU'RE DEAD I don't care IF YOU HAVE SKYCLAN BLOOD IN YOU GET AWAY.) HOW DARE YOU TELL HIM "Sometimes, I would give anything for things to be different." Before that she was talking to Sandstorm saying, "No Firestar loves you and we never got to know what we meant to each other. we wouldn't have been mates. You're not second best." Then Firestar's like, "Yeah see, Sandstorm. I love you." Then Spottedleaf has the nerves to say to him that, "Sometimes I would give anything for things to be different." (I hate her so much) SD(GET AWAY. I HATE YOU STOP POPPING UP IN EVERY BOOK.) She was in Into the Wild.. yeah I know she was alive, okay I guess. Then Fire and Ice, Forest of Secrets, Dangerous Path, Darkest Hour. I mean seriously, get away! Then second series she is in Moonrise, Dawn, Twilight, Sunset, Starlight... GET AWAY! LIKE OH MY STARCLAN YOU'RE DEAD. GO AWAY I don't care IF YOU'RE HELPING THEM, YOU SELFISH TWOFACE SO YOU'RE HORRIBLE. Then there's the third series. The Sight, Eclipse, Long Shadows, Sunrise. I DON'T CARE GET AWAY. Yeah you helped my Jay... WHY COULDN'T IT HAVE BEEN SOMEONE ELSE THOUGH. Then the fourth series, The Fourth Apprentice, Fading Echoes, Night Whispers, The Forgotten Warrior, The Last Hope... OH MY STARCLAN I HATE HER GET HER AWAY. OKAY I'M OKAY WITH THE LAST HOPE ONE CAUSE ALL THE STARCLAN WARRIORS CAME, BUT STILL. WHY IS SHE IN EVERY SERIES. SHE IS SO ANNOYING STICKING HER NOSE IN EVERYONE'S BUSINESS.
Next thing you know she'll probably magically end up in Tallstar's SE and magically end up in the short story book called Mistystar's Omen.

Please use proper English spelling and grammar. This will help other members understand you easier.

... that's all I have tl say. Three dots... Tallstar has a Super Edition? I knew about Mistystar's omen and I know about Dawn of The Clans the new series

Well I don't hate her, but yeah she is definitely Stalkerleaf

I like it better when you actually spell this right instead of talking like that. For example: b4, u, srsly, ur

And why are there quotation mark everywhere? I can't read it because of the random quotation marks everywhere...

I agree with Ivyfrost, your topic post was hard to read. Be sure you read the site rules

Skipping the five minutes required to decipher all that ( jk, jk), I like Spottedleaf because she was really dedicated to all the Clans, not just ThunderClan. In the first series, she was the one who prophesied that Firestar would save them all. And in the last book, she sacrificed herself so that her loved ones could go on to live. She was loyal, willing, and hardworking to the end.

I can't read your topic post at all.. could you please use proper english and grammar? It'll be a lot easier to read. Thanks.

I DON'T SPEAK YOUR LANGUAGE!!! Next time you post please speak english. And paragraphs.

Maybe the Erins should have kept her alive instead of killing her in the very first book? Idk.

She does seem to pop up everywhere, but that doesn't mean it's bad

i think her role in the first book was very minor, so if she got roles in other books, it should even it out. my thoughts are that the Erins put her in the first book as the cliche cat who's pretty, charming, but sadly, is also the friend who gets killed.

I don't like Spottedleaf, but I don't hate her either. I'm just... annoyed by her.

She has an obsession with Firestar (I think that the Erins once said that...) and won't keep well away from any of his kin. If my grandfather's ex-girlfriend appeared in my dreams I would bring out the Nunchucks. (Er, see a therapist, rather...)

Plus she didn''t really do anything in the first books that made her 'worthy'to stick around. So she fell in love with the hero, big deal... Bluestar did so much more and even Spottedleaf gets to appear more than any other significant cat.

Now that I can read this, I shall answer.

Why do you hate Spottedleaf? I don't understand. STARCLAN GIVES THE CLANS PROPHECIES!!! And since she's in Starclan, SHE GIVES THEM PROPHECIES! I mean, what did she do to get your hate, Nova? She's kind, loyal, and sweet. Do you have something against that? And Firestar never stopped loving her, so that's why he never stopped talking about her, or at least thinking about her.

There's my rant. Hope you enjoyed it!

wow, If only thumb down was back...

Sorry for the bad spelling before, I was on mobile

She's so annoying though D:

Oh, it's okay. I understand then. ALL IS WELL. (:

Well, I don't really like her or not. They don't show much of her.

Well in my opinion Spottedleaf is a little omnipresent, but it's a good thing! I think the Erins should've kept her alive though, because she appears in every book like Nova says. Spottedleaf is obviously very loyal to Firestar and ThunderClan, and she lasted until the end. I think its a good trait to have, and even though she is a little annoying at times, I'm glad Spottedleaf shows up!

umm, now that we cant thumb down, how is she getting thumb downed

I was so close to tears when she died! Its just so sad, not having such a sweet she-cat around. She's nice and dedicated to her Clan. What's so bad about her?

I tried to edit this too, but it's very confusing. Try to use proper grammer next time Nova. Anyway, this topic is ancient. Since no one's talking about it, I'll move it to the prison and lock it. I hope you guys don't mind.

Topic Moved To Prison and Locked