Is Firestar really that good?

First topic message reminder :

This may sound weird but I don't even like Firestar

He was pretty cool as apprentice/deputy/warrior, but when he became leader he went so downhill. He gave territory to ShadowClan, let kittypets into ThunderClan, and butted into WindClan's business StarClan knows how many times. So I guess I'm kind of for Firestar to die so we can see the era of Bramblestar!

Then any possible kits would be in danger of becoming added to the fresh-kill pile. o_o

Silverbreeze wrote:Then any possible kits would be in danger of becoming added to the fresh-kill pile. o_o

That would be true! XD Thunderclan would be a tough clan then!

A tough Clan that eats kits for breakfast along with an eagle. o3o Imagine that...

That would be insane, interesting and sad! XD

Yeah, if that was also the case then ThunderClan might be looked down upon by the three other Clans for eating kits. o3o

Yeah, and if that happened, the other clans might join forces to take down Thunderclan. O.o

You know what? Since Firestar was set to appear in the newest book the Last Hope, I've kind of liked him more and disliked him more.

I mean, he's obviously Erin's favorite. So that makes him more detestable.

But really, Firestar does have a place in everybody's heart because of his beginnings

I see how you see that. I thought that to but, I saw on her Facebook page that The Erin's Don't like Firestar that much!

I think in the last book of the series there will be a huge battle with the dark forest and Firestar fights Tigerstar and Brambleclaw fights Hawkfrost. Brambleclaw kills Hawkfrost but then Firestar is killed by Tigerstar. Brambleclaw faces his father and the battle begins. Brambleclaw kills Tigerstar but then suffers a fatal wound. As he dies he is happy because he has finally proved his loyalty. Then the power of 3 drive the other dark forest cats away and One of the power of the 3 become leader!