Hollyleaf

Well I was looking at this YouTube vie called: "Top Ten Evil Warrior Cats" and like number 8 or 7 was Hollyleaf! I don't think she' s evil! Just like she went insane? She only killed one cat and that was so he didn't kill Squirelflight's family.

Do you think Hollyleaf is evil? Tell me what you think in the comments.

No, not at all! It wasn't even her fault. I just think she's either OCD or really sensitive. So finding out about her family and then the thing in the fire about Ashfur trying to hurt Squirrelflight was too much for her. She had to have revenge.

No, Hollyleaf isn't evil! >.< Like Maplestream said, she only killed one cat, and it was to stop Ashfur from giving away everything at the Gathering in front of every Clan. Lionblaze also killed one cat, but he isn't considered evil. Hollyleaf's heart was in the right place, but she just acted too quickly. She was only trying to protect herself and her littermates. Sure, she did give away the secrets herself at the Gathering to have revenge on Leafpool and Squirrelflight, but what she did traumatized her. Hollyleaf really isn't evil.

I agree. But, what I do disagree with is:

Spoiler:

Remember in the last book? Well, then she did absolutely nothing wrong. And what was wrong with all of the clans knowing they were half clan? I mean, Hollyleaf didn't force Leafpool to give up her Medicine Cat name. I like how Hollyleaf is the first to forgive everyone, and is the most fair, even with what she's been through. All she ever wanted was to be the most loyal cat, always doing what's right, and being a good cat.. then she found out. She is the opposite of what she'd always wanted to be. And in the end, Hollyleaf was the most forgiving, caring, and trustworthy cat of them all. Plus,

Spoiler:

LExactly! She killed Ashfur, she becomes evil with some people!
But Graystripe kills Witeclaw, eh who care (yes I know that was an accident but, I haven't gotten that far, I'm a skipper! )
Well other guys kill and people are like, eh I don't care!

She didn't mean to kill anyone.

From things I've heard, she was just trying to make up for her foolish actions earlier in the story.

Well actually she meant to kill Ashfur...

Because she was angry with him and shocked at the discovery of her family. She wasn't thinking too clearly at the time. And that doesn't make her evil.

Yep! I knew she wasn't evil!

Hollyleaf is an awesome cat.