Warrior Cat Conspiracy Theories!

Notice something disturbing or mind blowing about Warrior Cats? Share them here! Learn something awesomely powerful or spine chillingly disturbing or boast and brag about your smartiness for connecting the missing links, or discuss hair brained ideas that may not be true, but you still support!
1. Creepy stalker Uncle
So.. everyone knows that in Bluestar's Prophecy, when she goes to visit Oakheart that in the next chapter, she finds out she's going to be a mom? But, when Goosefeather tries to convince her to give them up, and confesses that he followed her to fourtrees, so that's how he knows who the real father is. After some thinking, I realized that Goosefeather basically admitted he watched his neice.... okay, let's stop there before something bad happens.
2. Russetfur's motivation When I was reading Yellowfang's Secret and found out

Spoiler:

I was shocked... not just at the plot twist, but knowing why Russetfur supported Brokenstar. She wanted revenge on the cat that

Spoiler:

This made me wonder; Did Brokenstar know why Russetfur followed him, or did she keep it a locked secret in her heart. I have a nagging suspicion that they were in one of those romantic villain relationships, and killed Raggedstar as a team. The only unanswered question; is there illegitimate kits?

Leader out of her mind
When Bluestar gave Brightpaw her cruel temporary warrior name, Lostface, she left her an apprentice!

Apprentice till the end
Swiftpaw became an apprentice in the 2nd book in the whole series, Fire and Ice. He should've been a warrior in Forest of Secrets!

The wrong choice gone good
In the the 4th book in the new prophecy series, Starlight, Tallstar dies. But it is like he knew of Mudclaw's hostile ways! So he lets Onewhisker, the non hostile cat, become leader.

Aging faster?
In The Last Hope, it was said that

Spoiler:

and if I remember correctly, Dustpelt was a warrior when Spiderleg was still a kit! What's this?

Hollyleaf wasn't part of the three.
To me, it doesn't make sense that she was left out of the prophecy

Brightfrost wrote:Aging faster?
In The Last Hope, it was said that

Spoiler:

and if I remember correctly, Dustpelt was a warrior when Spiderleg was still a kit! What's this?

In the first series, Cedarheart becomes a warrior before Firestar. Yet in battle of the Clans, It said he remembered skyClan, and was one of the oldest cats in the clans! also the aging is all wrong, since firestar should have become an elder in the 3rd series!

Sunbeam wrote:

Brightfrost wrote:Aging faster?
In The Last Hope, it was said that

Spoiler:

and if I remember correctly, Dustpelt was a warrior when Spiderleg was still a kit! What's this?

In the first series, Cedarheart becomes a warrior before Firestar. Yet in battle of the Clans, It said he remembered skyClan, and was one of the oldest cats in the clans! also the aging is all wrong, since firestar should have become an elder in the 3rd series!

Cinderheart or Cinderpelt? I'm a bit confused here.

Cedarheart. He is a Shadowclan Tom.

Super-Fast Aging


Like Brightfrost said, some cats age SUPER fast! Like in RiverClan, there was an apprentice named Stonepaw. A couple books later, he became Stonestream. The book after was became a warrior, he was an elder, while everyone else in RiverClan that have been in the books FOREVER, are still warriors. What the heck?



Old/young couple


In the 1st series, Ferncloud was Fernkit. Dustpelt had been a warrior for at least 4 books by then. Fernkit becomes Fernpaw, and Dustpelt is all, "oh, Fernpaw! You just became an apprentice and I am already pretty much a senior warrior! Let's have 7 kits together!" So if I had to choose a human age for the both of them at that time, Dustpelt would be 30, and Fernpaw would be 8. Really?

Old/young couple
In the 1st series, Ferncloud was Fernkit. Dustpelt had been a warrior for at least 4 books by then. Fernkit becomes Fernpaw, and Dustpelt is all, "oh, Fernpaw! You just became an apprentice and I am already pretty much a senior warrior! Let's have 7 kits together!" So if I had to choose a human age for the both of them at that time, Dustpelt would be 30, and Fernpaw would be 8. Really?

No offense, but I'd be more concerned that their uncle and niece! (Ferncloud's mother is Brindleface, who is also Dustpelt's sister) In fact, a lot of warrior couples are uncle and neice. Whitewing and Thornclaw were supposed to become a couple until the fan's told Vicky they were related, (Brightheart, Whitewing's mother, is Thornclaw's sister. you can find hints in The Sight) and more recently, Rosepetal and Foxleap were interested in eachother until again, it was revealed that their uncle and niece. (Rosepetal's father, Spiderleg, is Foxleap's brother. There are several hints scattered throughout Fading Echoes and Night Whispers) But you're right, there's a lot of couples with major age difference, too. In Yellowfang's Secret, it was hinted that Yellowfang's brother had a crush on, coincidentally, an apprentice named Fernpaw, when he was at least several years older than her. But she chose someone else... who was nearly the same age as Nutwhisker. But the most disturbing, for me at least, is Spottedleaf and Firepaw. They were clearly interested in each other the moment they met, even though Firepaw was barely out of kittenhood.

Stareye wrote:

Old/young couple
In the 1st series, Ferncloud was Fernkit. Dustpelt had been a warrior for at least 4 books by then. Fernkit becomes Fernpaw, and Dustpelt is all, "oh, Fernpaw! You just became an apprentice and I am already pretty much a senior warrior! Let's have 7 kits together!" So if I had to choose a human age for the both of them at that time, Dustpelt would be 30, and Fernpaw would be 8. Really?

No offense, but I'd be more concerned that their uncle and niece! (Ferncloud's mother is Brindleface, who is also Dustpelt's sister) In fact, a lot of warrior couples are uncle and neice. Whitewing and Thornclaw were supposed to become a couple until the fan's told Vicky they were related, (Brightheart, Whitewing's mother, is Thornclaw's sister. you can find hints in The Sight) and more recently, Rosepetal and Foxleap were interested in eachother until again, it was revealed that their uncle and niece. (Rosepetal's father, Spiderleg, is Foxleap's brother. There are several hints scattered throughout Fading Echoes and Night Whispers) But you're right, there's a lot of couples with major age difference, too. In Yellowfang's Secret, it was hinted that Yellowfang's brother had a crush on, coincidentally, an apprentice named Fernpaw, when he was at least several years older than her. But she chose someone else... who was nearly the same age as Nutwhisker. But the most disturbing, for me at least, is Spottedleaf and Firepaw. They were clearly interested in each other the moment they met, even though Firepaw was barely out of kittenhood.

The age difference in mates that I find most disturbing is probably Pinestar and Leopardfoot (in Bluestar's prophecy). Pinestar was leader before Leopardfoot was even born!

I know, right, Streamstar? I read some of Bluestar's Prophecy and when it said Pinestar and Leopardfoot were mates, I felt like laughing. And Longtail and Mousefur are kind of mates, not really, but Longtail is barely an elder. He's just blind. Mousefur became an elder because she was old. And in Into the Wild, Longtail had just become a warrior and Mousefur was a senior warrior. But Ferncloud and Dustpelt bother the most, along with Pinestar and Leopardfoot.

Kit hates father?
In the very first book, Sandpaw 's father Redtail was killed. Yet she didn't react! Oooh...

Introduces kit names in Fire and Ice.
Have you ever noticed that kits never had names until halfway through Fire and Ice? It was pretty much like the leader naming your kits! Cloudkit was the first kit to have a NAME. Or rather, the first kit to have 'kit' at the end of name.

OK, I was talking to my friend the other day who also likes warrior cats and he saying an interesting theory that's probably not true and a bit silly and it does have holes but still interesting
The whole first 6 books we are seeing Rusty POV. But is what he is telling the actual truth? Perhaps Ravenpaw was a bit too paranoid and was convinced that Tigerstar killed Redtail when in fact he was actually innocent. Fireheart was convinced by Raven paw and decided to do something about it. In the 3rd book Fireheart chases Tigerstar away but Bluestar doesn't want her loyal warrior Fireheart to be accused of lying so she goes along with the story creating a cover up and casting Tigerstar as the evil character.

...Or have I been thinking too much into this? XD

I could continue this further and make it more disturbing... but it will take a few days...
Eh, why not?

Violetcloud wrote:I know, right, Streamstar? I read some of Bluestar's Prophecy and when it said Pinestar and Leopardfoot were mates, I felt like laughing. And Longtail and Mousefur are kind of mates, not really, but Longtail is barely an elder. He's just blind. Mousefur became an elder because she was old. And in Into the Wild, Longtail had just become a warrior and Mousefur was a senior warrior. But Ferncloud and Dustpelt bother the most, along with Pinestar and Leopardfoot.

I think that's more of an error. According to the history Mousefur's two years older than him, so she retired when she was six years old. Way too young to retire! Maybe this is another conspiracy theory; maybe she retired just so she could be with Longtail. There supposedly just friends, but it seems weird that two cats who spend every waking moment together, and when Longtail dies she never, never, EVER gets over her grief, is classified as "just friends".