who is better
+7
Scarlett
Honeystar
Caraway
Moon
Frost
Birdstar
Hawktalon
11 posters
Page 1 of 1
who is better
Well who's better: Firestar, Mistystar, Onestar, or Blackstar? I personally think Firestar even though he's all follow the warrior code and stuff (he's getting crazy)
Hawktalon- Loner
- Custom Rank : pure epicness :D
WarriorPoints : 4415
Posts : 49
Reputation : 2
Re: who is better
Mistystar all the way!
Then Onestar
Then Blackstar
and last (Im sorry this is just my opinion) Firestar
Then Onestar
Then Blackstar
and last (Im sorry this is just my opinion) Firestar
Birdstar- WindClan Warrior
- Custom Rank : 2 Birdyful 4 U
WarriorPoints : 7787
Posts : 2125
Reputation : 2765
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 42,000
Re: who is better
Its fine Applefur I really don't care, oh and oops I forgot to put has spoilers on the description
Hawktalon- Loner
- Custom Rank : pure epicness :D
WarriorPoints : 4415
Posts : 49
Reputation : 2
Re: who is better
At first though I really liked Firestar but as the series went I thought he would die soon but he didnt so it made me a little frustrated lol and Im just sick of him really
Birdstar- WindClan Warrior
- Custom Rank : 2 Birdyful 4 U
WarriorPoints : 7787
Posts : 2125
Reputation : 2765
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 42,000
Re: who is better
I agree with Applefur! Mistystar, Onestar, Blackstar then Firestar!
Frost- Global Moderator
- Custom Rank : Fab
WarriorPoints : 25603
Posts : 4113
Reputation : 5591
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 100,000
Re: who is better
I seem to like Mistystar the best.
Like what Applefur posted, I am also getting a bit sick of Firestar-he's too perfect, I don't really think that he has any humor or anything... Firestar is just a modest clan leader...
Like what Applefur posted, I am also getting a bit sick of Firestar-he's too perfect, I don't really think that he has any humor or anything... Firestar is just a modest clan leader...
Moon- Loner
- Custom Rank : Apprentice
WarriorPoints : 4473
Posts : 60
Reputation : 3
Re: who is better
Yeah but I like firestar the best because my deceased cat, Leroy, looked just like firestar. poor Leroy got killed because of purina cat food because we also fed my dog it and he also died because of it (I think it gave my cat and my dog kidney disease so if you have pets and you feed them purina cat food, don't!) Ps that's my theory
Hawktalon- Loner
- Custom Rank : pure epicness :D
WarriorPoints : 4415
Posts : 49
Reputation : 2
Re: who is better
i haven't read all the books, don't kill me.
i like...
1. Onestar (seems to be reasonably mature and good-natured)
2. Blackstar (awesomely sneaky and ninja-y)
3. Mistystar (pretty old and too many close-ups on her)
4. Firestar (self-explanatory. old, cliche, enough of him)
yeah just a sum of my opinion...
i like...
1. Onestar (seems to be reasonably mature and good-natured)
2. Blackstar (awesomely sneaky and ninja-y)
3. Mistystar (pretty old and too many close-ups on her)
4. Firestar (self-explanatory. old, cliche, enough of him)
yeah just a sum of my opinion...
Caraway- Global Moderator
- Custom Rank : Behind the Mask
WarriorPoints : 33777
Posts : 5555
Reputation : 7905
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 150,000
Re: who is better
Alll of those cats are pretty old [either by age or how long they've been in office as Leaders] by now. Time for some new blood. My fav right now, would have to be Mistystar [she's got the inheritance of Bluestar, Oakheart and Crookedstar- awesome cats of the old forest].
Maybe Blackstar cause he's tough and cool [like a Spetsnaz cat].
Onestar [idk what makes him 'good natured' to you Cheesestar] kinda of edgy (even for a WindClan Leader).
Firestar last, for reasons already pointed out. He and Tigerstar need to duke it out so we don't have to see them again. [Tigerstar was a great villain, but like Firestar, he's been on long enough too]
Maybe Blackstar cause he's tough and cool [like a Spetsnaz cat].
Onestar [idk what makes him 'good natured' to you Cheesestar] kinda of edgy (even for a WindClan Leader).
Firestar last, for reasons already pointed out. He and Tigerstar need to duke it out so we don't have to see them again. [Tigerstar was a great villain, but like Firestar, he's been on long enough too]
Honeystar- WindClan Warrior
- Custom Rank : The Sweetest Leader
WarriorPoints : 10404
Posts : 2451
Reputation : 154
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 25,000
Re: who is better
Firstar must be a living fossil by now. Mistystar.
Scarlett- IceClan Leader
- Custom Rank : The Immortal
WarriorPoints : 433469
Posts : 3168
Reputation : 15599
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 300,000
Re: who is better
They're all living fossils when you think about it. [Blackstar has got to be the oldest of the bunch. He was ShadowClan's Deputy when Firestar was still 'Rusty']
Honeystar- WindClan Warrior
- Custom Rank : The Sweetest Leader
WarriorPoints : 10404
Posts : 2451
Reputation : 154
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 25,000
Re: who is better
Yeah Firestar's like ancient
Frost- Global Moderator
- Custom Rank : Fab
WarriorPoints : 25603
Posts : 4113
Reputation : 5591
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 100,000
Re: who is better
Haha I agree with you Iceclaw. Firestar must be old by now.
My oreder is: Mistystar, Firestar, Onestar, Blackstar
My oreder is: Mistystar, Firestar, Onestar, Blackstar
Guest- Guest
Re: who is better
Lol you guys but my order is: Firestar, Mistystar, Blackstar, then Onestar because Onestar is kind of selfish and doesn't like Firestar anymore just because of Leafpool and Hollyleaf (not going any deeper in the books because cheesestar hasn't read them all) F.Y.I ive read them all
Last edited by Hawktalon on December 17th 2011, 06:31; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : typo)
Hawktalon- Loner
- Custom Rank : pure epicness :D
WarriorPoints : 4415
Posts : 49
Reputation : 2
Re: who is better
Maybe you should put blackstar at the end of your list, because he killed Stonefur
Lunarlight- Loner
- Custom Rank : FINE BULLY ME
WarriorPoints : 8734
Posts : 1287
Reputation : 5
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 9000
Re: who is better
Lol true but...Blackstar is like a ninja HI-YA! Mistystar. Ive always loved her! She was one of my favs in the series and when she became leader I was like YAY! Firestar and Tigerstar are old and I want a brand new fresh villain in the series and a brand new hero! ^.^
Birdstar- WindClan Warrior
- Custom Rank : 2 Birdyful 4 U
WarriorPoints : 7787
Posts : 2125
Reputation : 2765
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 42,000
Re: who is better
Double-posting within a 24 hour period is prohibited on Warrior Cats Forum. Next time please wait for a reply. If you wish to add any additional information to your previous post, please use the post Edit button. |
Whiteout- Loner
- Custom Rank : White Tiger
WarriorPoints : 8259
Posts : 201
Reputation : 1124
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 500,000
Re: who is better
1. Onestar (He's ninja!)
2. Mistystar (Bluestar's daughter and she's loyal and AWESOME)
3. Blackstar (Just because)
4. Firestar (He's not as cool as he used to be, he's just a normal clan leader)
2. Mistystar (Bluestar's daughter and she's loyal and AWESOME)
3. Blackstar (Just because)
4. Firestar (He's not as cool as he used to be, he's just a normal clan leader)
Redstar- ShadowClan Leader
- Custom Rank : WCF Granny
WarriorPoints : 10183
Posts : 3326
Reputation : 643
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 79,500
Re: who is better
1. Mistystar-Because she is sweet, loyal, and fair.
2. Blackstar-Because he defends his clan, is proud, and strong.
3.Onestar-He`s fast, proud, and willing to fight if he has to.
2. Blackstar-Because he defends his clan, is proud, and strong.
3.Onestar-He`s fast, proud, and willing to fight if he has to.
Guest- Guest
Re: who is better
Ok, ummm, I agree with you guys about Firestar, I liked him better when he was in the old forest.
Hawktalon- Loner
- Custom Rank : pure epicness :D
WarriorPoints : 4415
Posts : 49
Reputation : 2
Re: who is better
I will always be a Blackstar fan I love his personality
Hazelstar- Loner
- Custom Rank : Skyclan's Leader
WarriorPoints : 7098
Posts : 463
Reputation : 142
Warrior Information
Attack Power : 30,000
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|